Abstract
Early forest re-establishment in landforms constructed from materials such as overburden or mine waste is partly determined by nitrogen (N) availability in reclamation covers. Here we examined whether the ecosystem model ecosys which simulates key processes governing N availability such as mineralization, plant N uptake and N return to soil through litterfall could be used to forecast potential N limitations for forest re-establishment in these constructed landforms. In this study, N cycling was simulated and tested against measured soil, foliar and surface litter N concentrations with three soil covers differing in thickness (35, 50, and 100 cm) in a 17-year-old forest reclamation site and in an analogue natural forested site in northern Alberta. Overall, results from this study demonstrated the applicability of the ecosys model in predicting nutrient cycling in reclaimed upland forestlands. Results of this study highlight the importance of optimum cover depth to ensure sufficient N is available for plant growth. Even though the modelled net N mineralization, N uptake and thereby plant productivity increased with cover depth, the foliar and surface litter N concentrations did not. A non-linear relationship between total soil nitrogen (TN) stocks and modelled net N mineralization indicated that cover depth, which determines TN stock, had little effect on net primary productivity beyond a threshold TN. This threshold was 17 Mg N ha−1, similar to TN for the 100 cm cover, giving a net N mineralization rate of ~ 3.5 g N m−2 year−1, and this was attributed to reduced microbial activity in deeper soil layers.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Alberta Environment (2010) Guidelines for Reclamation to Forest Vegetation in the Athabasca Oil Sands Region, 2nd edn. Terrestrial Subgroup of the Reclamation Working Group of the Cumulative Environmental Management Association, Fort McMurray
Alberta Environment and Parks (2014) Airdata. http://airdata.alberta.ca/aepContent/Reports/DataReports.aspx. Accessed 14 Jan 2015
Alberta Environment and Water (2012) Best management practices for conservation of reclamation materials in the mineable oil Sands region of Alberta. Best Management Practices Task Group of the Reclamation Working Group of the Cumulative Environmental Management Association, Fort McMurray
Ballard TM, Carter RE (1986) Evaluating forest stand nutrient status. Land Manage Report No. 20. Ministry of Forests, Victoria
Barber SA, Silberbush M (1984) Plant root morphology and nutrient uptake. In: Barber SA, Bouldin DR (eds) Roots, nutrient and water influx, and plant growth. Amer Soc Agron Spec Publ No. 49, Madison, pp 65–87
Beckingham JD, Archibald JH (1996) Field guide to ecosites of northern Alberta. Natural Resources Canada, Northern Forestry Centre, Edmonton
Boese CD (2003) The design and installation of a field instrumentation program for the evaluation of soil-atmosphere water fluxes in a vegetated cover over saline/sodic shale overburden. Dissertation, University of Saskatchewan
Boone RD (1992) Influence of sampling date and substrate on nitrogen mineralization: comparison of laboratory-incubation and buried-bag methods for two Massachusetts forest soils. Can J For Res 22:1895–1900
Campbell EE, Paustian K (2015) Current developments in soil organic matter modeling and the expansion of model applications: a review. Environ Res Lett 10:1–36
Carmosini N, Devito KJ, Prepas EE (2003) Net nitrogen mineralization and nitrification in trembling aspen forest soil on the Boreal Plain. Can J For Res 33:2262–2268
CEMA (2006) Land capability classification system for forest ecosystems in the oil sands, 3rd edn. A document prepared for Alberta Environment by the Cumulative Environmental Management Association, Edmonton
Chang S, Yan E, Hu Y (2010) Soil nitrogen indicators for land reclamation policy development for forest ecosystems in the oil sands region of Alberta. Report submitted to the Cumulative Environmental Management Association, Fort McMurray, AB
Cole DW, Rapp M (1981) Elemental cycling in forest ecosystem. In: Reichle DE (ed) Dynamic properties of forest ecosystems. Cambridge University Press, London, pp 341–409
Das Gupta S (2015) Spatial variability in disturbed boreal ecosystems: aboveground and belowground controls. Dissertation, University of Alberta
De Vries W, Solberg S, Dobbertin M, Sterba H, Laubhann D, van Oijen M, Evans C, Gundersen P, Kros J, Wamelink GWW, Reinds GJ, Sutton MA (2009) The impact of nitrogen deposition on carbon sequestration by European forests and heathlands. For Ecol Manag 258:1814–1823
Devito KJ, Westbrook CJ, Schiff SL (1999) Nitrogen mineralization and nitrification in upland and peatland forest soils in two Canadian Shield catchments. Can J For Res 29:1793–1804
Drozdowksi B, Bauman L, Underwood A, Faught B (2014) Carbon dynamics in reclaimed and natural landscapes at the operations of Syncrude Canada Ltd. Report prepared for Syncrude Canada Ltd. Alberta Innovates - Technology Futures, Edmonton
Duan M, Chang SX (2015) Responses of lodgepole pine (Pinus contorta) and white spruce (Picea glauca) to fertilization in some reconstructed boreal forest soils in the oil sands region. Ecol Eng 84:354–361
Duan M, House J, Chang SX (2015) Limiting factors for lodgepole pine (Pinus contorta) and white spruce (Picea glauca) growth differ in some reconstructed sites in the Athabasca oil sands region. Ecol Eng 75:323–331
Elshorbagy A, Barbour SL (2007) A probabilistic approach for design and hydrologic performance assessment of reconstructed watersheds. J Geotech Geoenviron Eng 133:1110–1118
Elshorbagy A, Jutla A, Barbour SL, Kells J (2005) System dynamics approach to assess the sustainability of reclamation of disturbed watersheds. Can J Civ Eng 32:144–158
Elshorbagy A, Barbour SL, Qualizza C (2006) Multi-criterion decision making approach to assess the performance of reconstructed watersheds. In: Castelletti A, Sessa RS (eds) Topics on system analysis and integrated water resource management. Elsevier, Amsterdam, pp 257–269
Environment Canada (2014) Canadian Climate Normals 1981–2010. http://climate.weather.gc.ca/climate_normals/results_1981_2010_e.html?stnID=2519&lang=e&StationName=fortmcmurray&SearchType=Contains&stnNameSubmit=go&dCode=1&dispBack=1. Accessed 10 Aug 2014
Federer CA (1983) Nitrogen mineralization and nitrification:depth variation in four New England forest soils. Soil Sci Soc Am J 47:1008–1014
Finzi AC, Norby RJ, Calfapietra C, Gallet-Budynek A, Gielen B, Holmes WE, Hoosbeek MR, Iversen CM, Jackson RB, Kubiske ME, Ledford J, Liberloo M, Oren R, Polle A, Pritchard S, Zak DR, Schlesinger WH, Ceulemans R (2007) Increases in nitrogen uptake rather than nitrogen-use efficiency support higher rates of temperate forest productivity under elevated CO2. PNAS 104:14014–14019
Fung MYP, Macyk TM (2000) Reclamation of oil sands mining areas. In: Barnhisel RI, Darmody RG, Daniels WL (eds) Reclamation of drastically disturbed lands. Agron Monograph 41. ASA, CSSA and SSSA, Madison, pp 755–774
Garrah K, Gulyas G, Straker J, Thrower J (2013) South Bison Hill research synthesis – vegetation overstory response to reclamation cover depth. Report prepared for Syncrude Canada Ltd. Integral Ecology Group Ltd, Victoria
Goodale CL, Apps M, Birdsey R, Field C, Heath L, Houghton R, Jenkins J, Kohlmaier G, Kurz W, Liu S, Nabuurs G, Nilsson S, Shvidenko A (2002) Forest carbon sinks in the northern hemisphere. Ecol Appl 12:891–899
Gower ST, Krankina ON, Olson RJ, Apps MJ, Linder S, Wang C (2001) Net primary production and carbon allocation patterns of boreal forest ecosystems. Ecol Appl 11:1395–1411
Grant RF (1993) Simulation model of soil compaction and root growth. I. Model development. Plant Soil 150:1–14
Grant RF (1995) Salinity, water use and yield of maize: testing of the mathematical model ecosys. Plant Soil 172:309–322
Grant RF (1998) Simulation in ecosys of root growth response to contrasting soil water and nitrogen. Ecol Model 107(2):237–264
Grant RF (2001) A review of the Canadian ecosystem model ecosys. In: Shaffer M (ed) Modeling carbon and nitrogen dynamics for soil management. CRC Press, Boca Raton, pp 173–264
Grant RF (2013) Modelling changes in nitrogen cycling to sustain increases in forest productivity under elevated atmospheric CO2 and contrasting site conditions. Biogeoscience 10:7703–7721
Grant RF (2014) Nitrogen mineralization drives the response of forest productivity to soil warming: modelling in ecosys vs. measurements from the Harvard soil heating experiment. Ecol Model 288:38–46
Grant RF (2015) Ecosystem CO2 and CH4 exchange in a mixed tundra and a fen within a hydrologically diverse Arctic landscape: 2. Modeled impacts of climate change. J Geophys Res Biogeosci 120:1388–1406
Grant RF, Nalder IA (2000) Climate change effects on net carbon exchange of a boreal aspen-hazelnut forest: estimates from the ecosystem model ecosys. Glob Change Biol 6:183–200
Grant RF, Nyborg M, Laidlaw J (1993) Evolution of nitrous oxide from soil: II. Experimental results and model testing. Soil Sci 156:266–277
Grant RF, Black TA, den Hartog G, Berry JA, Neumann HH, Blanken PD, Yang PC, Russell C, Nalder IA (1999) Diurnal and annual exchanges of mass and energy between an aspen-hazelnut forest and the atmosphere: testing the mathematical model Ecosys with data from the BOREAS experiment. J Geophys Res 104:27699–27717
Grant CD, Ward SC, Morley SC (2007a) Return of ecosystem function to restored bauxite mines in Western Australia. Restor Ecol 15:94–103
Grant RF, Arkebauer TJ, Dobermann A, Hubbard KG, Schimelfenig TT, Suyker AE, Verma SB, Walters DT (2007b) Net biome productivity of irrigated and rainfed maize–soybean rotations: modeling vs. measurements. Agron J 99:1404–1423
Grant RF, Black TA, Humphreys E, Morgenstern K (2007c) Changes in net ecosystem productivity with forest age following clearcutting of a coastal Douglas-fir forest: testing a mathematical model with eddy covariance measurements along a forest chronosequence. Tree Physiol 27(1):115–131
Grant RF, Barr AG, Black TA, Margolis HA, McCaughey JH, Trofymow JA (2010) Net ecosystem productivity of temperate and boreal forests after clearcutting—a Fluxnet-Canada synthesis. Tellus B 62:475–496
Grant RF, Baldocchi DD, Ma S (2012) Ecological controls on net ecosystem productivity of a seasonally dry annual grassland under current and future climates: Modelling with ecosys. Agric For Meteorol 152:189–200
Grant RF, Dyck M, Puurveen C (2020) Nitrogen and phosphorus control carbon sequestration in agricultural ecosystems: modelling carbon, nitrogen and phosphorus balances at the Breton Plots with ecosys under historical and future climates. Can J Soil Sci. https://doi.org/10.1139/CJSS-2019-0132
Hansen EA (1994) A guide for determining when to fertilize hybrid poplar plantations. Res Pap NC-319. U.S. Department of Agriculture, North Central Forest Experiment Station, St. Paul
Hemstock SS (2008) Plant productivity, soil microorganisms, and soil nitrogen cycling in peat amendments used for oil sands reclamation. Dissertation, University of Alberta
Hemstock SS, Quideau SA, Chanasyk DS (2010) Nitrogen availability from peat amendments used in boreal oil sands reclamation. Can J Soil Sci 90:165–175
Hilderman JN (2011) Net percolation as a function of topographic variation in a reclamation cover over a saline-sodic overburden dump. Dissertation, University of Saskatchewan
Huang M, Barbour SL, Carey SK (2015) The impact of reclamation cover depth on the performance of reclaimed shale overburden at an oil sands mine in northern Alberta, Canada. Hydrol Process 29(12):2840–2854
Jerabkova L, Prescott CE, Kishchuk BE (2006) Nitrogen availability in soil and forest floor of contrasting types of boreal mixedwood forests. Can J For Res 36:112–122
Jones DL, Magthab EA, Gleeson DB, Hill PW, Sánchez-Rodríguez AR, Roberts P, Ge T, Murphy DV (2018) Microbial competition for nitrogen and carbon is as intense in the subsoil as in the topsoil. Soil Biol Biochem 117:72–82
Kaye JP, Hart SC (1997) Competition for nitrogen between plants and soil microorganisms. Trends Ecol Evol 12:139–143
Kelln C, Barbour L, Qualizza C (2007) Preferential flow in a reclamation cover: hydrological and geochemical response. Can J Soil Sci 133(10):1277–1289
Kessler S, Barbour SL, van Rees KC, Dobchuk BS (2010) Salinization of soil over saline-sodic overburden from the oil sands in Alberta. Can J Soil Sci 90:637–647
Kimball JS, Zhao M, McDonald KC, Running SW (2006) Satellite remote sensing of terrestrial net primary production for the pan-arctic basin and Alaska. Mitig Adapt Strat Glob Change 11(4):783–804
Kronzucker HJ, Siddiqi MY, Glass ADM (1997) Conifer root discrimination against soil nitrate and the ecology of forest succession. Nature 385:59–61
Kurz WA, Shaw CH, Boisvenue C, Stinson G, Metsaranta J, Leckie D, Dyk A, Smyth C, Neilson ET (2013) Carbon in Canada’s boreal forest—a synthesis. Environ Rev 21:260–292
Kwak J-H, Chang SX, Naeth MA, Schaaf W (2015) Coarse woody debris extract decreases nitrogen availability in two reclaimed oil sands soils in Canada. Ecol Eng 84:13–21
Lambers H, Poorter H (1992) Inherent variation in growth rate between higher plants: a search for physiological causes and ecological consequences. Adv Ecol Res 23:187–261
Lanoue AVL (2003) Phosphorus content and accumulation of carbon and nitrogen in boreal forest soils. Dissertation, University of Alberta
Macdonald SE, Landhäusser SM, Skousen J, Franklin J, Frouz J, Hall S, Jacobs DF, Quideau S (2015) Forest restoration following surface mining disturbance: challenges and solutions. New For 46:703–732
MacKenzie MD, Quideau SA (2010) Microbial community structure and nutrient availability in oil sands reclaimed boreal soils. Appl Soil Ecol 44:32–41
MacKenzie MD, Quideau SA (2012) Laboratory-based nitrogen mineralization and biogeochemistry of two soils used in oil sands reclamation. Can J Soil Sci 92:131–142
Macyk TM (1999) Soil monitoring at the 30 dump overburden area. Report prepared for Syncrude Canada Ltd. Alberta Research Council Inc., Edmonton
Mahendrappa MK, Salonius PO (1982) Nutrient dynamics and growth response in a fertilized black spruce stand. Soil Sci Soc Am J 46:127–133
McMillian R, Quideau SA, MacKenzie MD, Biryukova O (2007) Nitrogen mineralization and microbial activity in oil sands reclaimed boreal forest soils. J Environ Qual 36:1470–1478
Meiers G (2002) The use of field measurements of hydraulic conductivity to characterize the performance of reclamation covers with time. Dissertation, University of Saskatchewan
Mekonnen ZA, William Riley J, Grant RF (2018) Accelerated nutrient cycling and increased light competition will lead to 21st century shrub expansion in North American Arctic tundra. J Geophys Res Biogeosci 123:1683–1701
Merlin M, Landhäusser SL (2019) Seasonal patterns of water uptake in Populus tremuloides and Picea glauca on a boreal reclamation site is species specific and modulated by capping soil depth and slope position. Plant Soil 439:487–504. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11104-019-04029-6
Mezbahuddin M, Grant RF, Hirano T (2014) Modelling effects of seasonal variation in water table depth on net ecosystem CO2 exchange of a tropical peatland. Biogeoscience 11:577–599
Michelson IH, Ingvarsson PK, Robinson KM, Edlund E, Eriksson ME, Nilsson O, Jansson S (2018) Autumn senescence in aspen is not triggered by day length. Physiol Plant 162:123–134
Min X, Siddiqi MY, Guy RD, Glass ADM, Kronzucker HJ (2000) A comparative kinetic analysis of nitrate and ammonium influx in two early-successional tree species of temperate and boreal forest ecosystems. Plant Cell Environ 23:321–328
Nadelhoffer KJ, Aber JD, Melillo JM (1985) Fine roots, net primary production, and soil nitrogen availability: a new hypothesis. Ecology 66(4):1377–1390
Naeth MA, Wilkinson SR, Mackenzie DD, Archibald HA, Powter CB (2013) Potential of LFH Mineral Soil Mixes for Land Reclamation in Alberta. OSRIN Report No. TR-35. Oil Sands Research and Information Network, University of Alberta, Edmonton, Alberta
Nelson DW, Sommers LE (1996) Total carbon, organic carbon, and organic matter. In: Sparks DL et al (eds) Methods of soil analysis, Part 3. SSSA Book Series, Madison, pp 961–1010
Nienstaedt H, Zasada JC (1990) Picea glauca (Moench) Voss: white spruce. In: Burns RM, Honkala BH (eds) Silvics of North America: vol 1. Conifers. USDA Forest Service, Washington, DC, pp 204–226
Nitschke CR, Waeber PO, Klaassen JW, Dordel J, Innes JL, Aponte C (2017) Nutrient uptake and use efficiency in co-occurring plants along a disturbance and nutrient availability gradient in the boreal forests of the southwest Yukon, Canada. J Veg Sci 28:69–81
O’Kane Consultants Inc (2013) Instrumented watershed monitoring program monitoring data summary report for the period January 2012 to December 2012. Report No. 690/01–46. Prepared for Syncrude Canada Ltd., Fort McMurray, AB
O’Kane Consultants Inc (2014) Instrumented watershed monitoring program monitoring data summary report for the period January 2013 to December 2013. Report No. 690/01–53. Prepared for Syncrude Canada Ltd., Fort McMurray, AB
Pastor J (1987) Successional changes in nitrogen availability as a potential factor contributing to spruce declines in boreal North America. Can J For Res 17:1394–1400
Persson T, Wiren A (1995) Nitrogen mineralization and potential nitrification at different depths in acidic forest soils. Plant Soil 168:55–65
Quideau SA, Norris CE, Rees F, Dyck M, Samadi N, Oh S-W (2017) Carbon, nitrogen, and phosphorus release from peat and forest floor-based cover soils used during oil sands reclamation. Can J Soil Sci 97:757–768
Rowland S, Prescott CE, Grayston SJ, Quideau SA, Bradfield GE (2009) Recreating a functioning forest soil in reclaimed oil sands in northern Alberta: An approach for measuring success in ecological restoration. J Environ Qual 38:1580–1590
Schuwirth N, Borgwardt F, Domisch S, Friedrichs M, Kattwinkel M, Kneis D, Kuemmerlen M, Langhans SD, Martínez-López J, Vermeiren P (2019) How to make ecological models useful for environmental management? Ecol Model 411:108784
Shenoy A, Kielland K, Johnstone JF (2013) Effects of fire severity on plant nutrient uptake reinforce alternate pathways of succession in boreal forests. Plant Ecol 214:587–596
Sobek AA, Skousen JG, Fisher SE (2000) Chemical and physical properties of overburdens and minesoils. In: Barnhisel RI, Darmody RG, Daniels WL (eds) Reclamation of drastically disturbed lands. Agron Monogr 41. ASA, CSSA, and SSSA, Madison, pp 77–104
Stinson G, Kurz WA, Smyth CE, Neilson ET, Dymond CC, Metsaranta JM, Boisvenue C, Rampley GJ, Li Q, White TM, Blain D (2011) An inventory-based analysis of Canada’s managed forest carbon dynamics, 1990 to 2008. Glob Change Biol 17(6):2227–2244
Stottlemeyer R, Toczydlowski D (1999) Nitrogen mineralization in a mature boreal forest, Isle Royale, Michigan. J Environ Qual 28:709–720
Struecker J, Joergensen RG (2015) Microorganisms and their substrate utilization patterns in topsoil and subsoil layers of two silt loams, differing in soil organic C accumulation due to colluvial processes. Soil Biol Biochem 91:310–317
Todd MCL, Adams MA, Grierson PF (2000) Mineralisation of nitrogen in a chronosequence of rehabilitated bauxite mines. Aust J Soil Res 38:435–451
Van Cleve K, Oliver L, Schlentner R, Viereck LA, Dyrness CT (1983) Productivity and nutrient cycling in taiga forest ecosystems. Can J For Res 13:747–766
Wang GG, Klinka K (1997) White spruce foliar nutrient concentrations in relation to tree growth and soil nutrient amounts. For Ecol Mgmt 98:89–99
Welegedara NPY, Grant RF, Quideau SA, Landhäusser SM, Merlin M, Lloret E (2019) Modelling plant water relations and net primary productivity as affected by reclamation cover depth in reclaimed forestlands of Northern Alberta. Plant Soil 446(1):627–654. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11104-019-04363-9
Yarmuch M (2003) Measurement of soil physical parameters to evaluate soil structure quality in reclaimed oil sands soils, Alberta, Canada. Dissertation. University of Alberta
Acknowledgements
Funding for the study was provided by the Land Reclamation International Graduate School (LRIGS) at the University of Alberta, the NSERC Collaborative Research and Training Experience (CREATE) Program, and Canadian Oil Sands Network for Research and Development (CONRAD). Computational facilities for the modelling project were provided by Compute Canada and WestGrid high-performance computing infrastructure, and the University of Alberta. The great support in providing field data by Syncrude Canada limited is very much appreciated and special thanks goes to Marty Yarmuch and Bonnie Drozdowski for providing support to get field data. We would like to acknowledge Emily Lloret, Cassandra McKenzie, Jela Burkus, Luke Donnan, Kelti Eaton, Melanie Luong for field data acquisition and laboratory assistance.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
Responsible Editor: Kate Lajtha
Publisher's Note
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Electronic supplementary material
Below is the link to the electronic supplementary material.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Welegedara, N.P.Y., Grant, R.F., Quideau, S.A. et al. Modelling nitrogen mineralization and plant nitrogen uptake as affected by reclamation cover depth in reclaimed upland forestlands of Northern Alberta. Biogeochemistry 149, 293–315 (2020). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10533-020-00676-5
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10533-020-00676-5