Flax fabric-reinforced epoxy pipes subjected to lateral compression
Introduction
Natural fibres are readily available in many countries, and there is considerable potential for their application as a sustainable construction material [1], [2] due to increasing environmental concern [3], [4]. In order to achieve a more sustainable construction industry, the United States (US) Department of Agriculture and the US Department of Energy have set goals of having at least 10% of all basic chemical building blocks to be created from renewable and plant-based sources by 2020, increasing to 50% by 2050 [5], [6]. Additionally, the International Council for Research and Innovation in Building and Construction (CIB) published its Agenda 21 on Sustainable Construction (CIB Report Publication 237) in 1999, placing emphasis on the use of agricultural waste products and other biological materials as building products for further sustainable construction practices [7].
The substitution of synthetic fibres for natural fibres has recently become a focus in composite research [8], [9], [10], [11], [12], [13], [14], [15]. For example, Dittenber and Ganga Rao [12] compared the physical and mechanical properties of glass fibre to more than 20 commonly used natural fibres such as sisal, ramie, kenaf, jute, hemp, flax, coir, and cotton, and found that of the various natural fibres tested, flax fibre offered the best potential combination of low mass, low cost, high strength, and high stiffness.
The behaviour of structural members of various configurations made or strengthened with flax fabric-reinforced epoxy (FFRE) laminates has been widely studied previously [16], [17], [18], [19]. Such research shows close similarity in tensile strength between FFRE and glass fibre reinforced epoxy (GFRE) composites [18], indicating the substantial potential for FFRE composites to be used in structural components, especially in developing countries where flax fibres are often available in abundance [16], [17], [20].
GFRP composites used in pipes, tanks and corrosion-resistant applications represent the third largest group of glass fibre applications in Europe [2], [21], such that this industry sector provides many potential opportunities for the application of flax fibres in composite pipe manufacture. FFRE offers many advantages for manufacturing pipes when compared to conventional pipe materials such as polyvinyl chloride (PVC), glass fibre reinforced plastic (GRP), steel, and concrete. FFRE resists corrosion [13], [22] and no protective coating is required on the internal and external pipe surfaces when compared to their steel counterparts. PVC and GRP pipes are commonly used to address the corrosion issue, and these alternative pipe systems are manufactured from non-sustainable resources. The application of synthetic fibres for the manufacture of water pipes may be a health hazard if any synthetic fibre debris causes contamination of the water passing along the pipe, whereas natural fibre debris may result in such health hazards being avoided [23]. Additionally, FFRE composites are approximately 16% the density of steel and 50% the density of concrete [24], such that FFRE pipes are expected to be more convenient for transportation and installation when compared to their steel and concrete counterparts. Furthermore, the reduced mass of FFRE results in lower inertia forces being attracted during dynamic loadings such as earthquake excitations when compared to their steel and concrete counterparts.
Although FFRE composites have the potential to be used in pipe manufacture, several challenges for practical application of FFRE pipes still exist. One major concern is the durability of FFRE composites [25], [26], with the shortage of existing data related to the durability of FFRE being one major challenge that needs to be overcome prior to widespread acceptance of FFRE for pipe manufacture. FFRE composites have relatively poor moisture resistance because of the presence of hydroxyl and other polar groups in the fibres when compared to glass or carbon FRP composites [27], [28], and flax fibres with a high moisture uptake have weak fibre/matrix interfacial bonding which may compromise the mechanical properties of the FFRE composites [28], [29]. It is therefore necessary to enhance the hydrophobicity of the natural fibres by treating them with suitable coupling agents or by coating the fibres with an appropriate resin matrix to generate FFRE composites having better mechanical properties and superior durability performance [13], [30]. A more comprehensive analysis should involve potential fracture mechanics and the fatigue behaviour of FFRE pipes. Other issues to be considered are that the void ratio and void behaviour may be different for gravity flow when compared to low, moderate and high-pressure pipe flow, and that the life span of FFRE pipes will merit attention and comparison against the performance of existing pipe materials. Also, the pressure requirements for different pipe applications will vary and the design requirements will be dependent on the application. By properly defining the required specification, the performance of the FFRE composite pipes can be properly benchmarked and assessed.
Lateral compression can arise within buried pipelines during their operation from the weight of the soil above the pipe (dead load) or by vehicles traversing the pipeline on the ground surface [31], [32]. Tubes are also commonly used as energy-absorbing devices that are subjected to lateral compression during impact events. For example, tubes are used to improve the crashworthiness of vehicles such as cars, lifts, aircraft, and ships [33], [34], crash barriers [35], road bridges, offshore structures, and oil tankers [34], or tubes are used to confine concrete columns or soil, with the application of that being associated with reinforcement of concrete columns or soil in infrastructure applications [16], [17]. In this study the term ‘tube’ is used to refer to cylindrical hollow sections used for structural purposes such as energy-absorbing devices or concrete filled steel/composite tubes used in infrastructure applications, whereas the term ‘pipe’ is used to refer to a hollow tubular section that transmits fluids or gasses.
The aim of the study reported herein was to address the feasibility of FFRE pipes to replace pipes manufactured from non-sustainable resources, such as GRP and PVC pipes, from structural performance perspective. If so, FFRE pipes would have a substantial potential to be used especially in developing countries where flax fibres are available in abundance. In this study, the response of FFRE pipes with varying diameters and fabric layers when subjected to lateral compression loading was investigated. A complete explanation of the pipe fabrication and testing methodology is provided, and pipe crown vertical deformation, pipe springline horizontal deformation, strength, circumferential strain at different locations, and pipe failure mechanisms are evaluated. Additionally, energy absorption and specific energy absorbed (SEA: energy absorbed per unit mass) characteristics of FFRE pipes presented herein are compared to energy-absorbing tubes with different materials.
Parallel-plate loading is a standardised test for ensuring that the stiffness and strength of a pipe subjected to lateral compression meets specified levels of performance [36], [37]. There are many studies in the literature which focus on steel pipe/tube lateral compression, with the main concerns of these studies being the effect of different geometric parameters on the energy absorption properties of the tubes [38], [39], [40], [41], [42], [43]. Research on lateral compression of composite pipes/tubes has been previously undertaken by many researchers [44], [45], [46], [47], [48], [49], [50], [51], [52]. Faria [47], Sebaey and Mahdi [48], Park et al. [49], Gupta and Abbas [45], and Abdewi et al. [46] investigated the lateral compression behaviour of composite pipes manufactured from glass-fibre resins, and showed that inter-layer delamination and fibre breakage were the main pipe damage mechanisms. El-Sobkhy and Singace [44] experimentally investigated the deformation of double-skin profiled polyethylene pipes subjected to lateral compression and concluded that increasing the pipe diameter improved the pipe energy absorbed and pipe specific energy absorbed. Niknejad et al. [50], Moeinifard et al. [51], and Rouzegar et al. [52] performed experimental studies to investigate the effect of pipe geometric properties on structural behaviour of E-glass fibre composite tubes when subjected to lateral compression, with the results showing that the total energy absorption capacity of the larger specimens is more than for smaller tubes.
Section snippets
Materials
Commercial balanced plain-woven (bidirectional) flax fabric with a mass per unit area of 550 g/m2 manufactured by Lineo located in France [53], see Fig. 1a, and 105 West System epoxy and its 209 extra slow hardener with the mixture ratio being 3.5:1 by mass, respectively [54], were used to manufacture pipe specimens. The moisture content of the flax fabric before composite manufacture was measured using oven-drying tests on 10 flax fabric samples according to ASTM D2495 [55], with the tests
Monotonic versus cyclic characteristics
Lateral compression testing was conducted using deformation-controlled loading, and to amalgamate the three lateral compression testing conducted for each specific pipe group, the average lateral compression load-vertical displacement relationship was calculated. The average lateral compression load–displacement relationships for the D60 pipes with 2, 3, and 4 fabric layers when subjected to monotonic and cyclic loadings were compared in Fig. 6. The vertical displacement normalised by pipe
Conclusions
Lateral compression of flax fabric-reinforced epoxy (FFRE) pipes with different flax fabric layers and internal diameters were investigated. Pipe invert vertical deformation, pipe springline horizontal deformation, strength, energy absorbed, specific energy absorbed and failure mechanism were investigated, alongside circumferential strain measured on the internal surface of the crown and invert, as well as strain measured on both internal and external surfaces of the springline and haunch.
Acknowledgement
The authors gratefully acknowledge Adhesive Technologies NZ Ltd for providing the epoxy resin and hardener used in this research.
Author statement
- •
Study conception and design:
Eyvazinejad Firouzsalari, Chouw, and Jayaraman
- •
Acquisition of data:
Eyvazinejad Fioruzsalari
- •
Analysis and interpretation of data:
Eyvazinejad Firouzsalari
- •
Drafting of manuscript:
Eyvazinejad Firouzsalari
- •
Critical revision:
Dizhur, Jayaraman, Ingham
References (90)
- et al.
Carbon storage potential in natural fiber composites
Resour Conserv Recycl
(2003) - et al.
Mechanical behaviour of particulate hybrid composite laminates as potential building materials
Constr Build Mater
(1995) - et al.
Critical review of recent publications on use of natural composites in infrastructure
Compos Part A Appl Sci Manuf
(2012) - et al.
Flax fibre and its composites – a review
Compos Part B Eng
(2014) - et al.
Crashworthiness characteristics of flax fibre reinforced epoxy tubes for energy absorption application
Mater Des
(2013) - et al.
Lateral crushing of empty and polyurethane-foam filled natural flax fabric reinforced epoxy composite tubes
Compos Part B Eng
(2014) - et al.
Influence of water ageing on mechanical properties and damage events of two reinforced composite materials: flax–fibres and glass–fibres
Mater Des
(2011) - et al.
Reinforced concrete beams strengthened with externally bonded natural flax FRP plates
Compos Part B Eng
(2016) - et al.
Application of natural fiber reinforced composites to trenchless rehabilitation of underground pipes
Compos Struct
(2008) - et al.
Environmental effects on the durability and the mechanical performance of flax fiber/bio-epoxy composites
Compos Part B Eng
(2019)
Influence of hydrothermal ageing on the fatigue behaviour of a unidirectional flax-epoxy laminate
Compos Part B Eng
A review of recent developments in natural fibre composites and their mechanical performance
Compos Part A Appl Sci Manuf
A review on the degradability of polymeric composites based on natural fibres
Mater Des
An experimental investigation of the energy dissipation of a number of car bumpers under quasi-static lateral loads
Int J Impact Eng
Collapsible impact energy absorbers: an overview
Thin-Walled Struct
Design and simulation of a sequential kinking guardrail terminal
Int J Impact Eng
Phenomena associated with the crushing of metal tubes between rigid plates
Int J Solids Struct
Study of lateral compression of round metallic tubes
Thin-Walled Struct
Collapse of pressurized elastoplastic tubular members under lateral loads
Int J Mech Sci
Profiled polymer pipes as re-usable energy absorption elements
Int J Mech Sci
Lateral collapse of composite cylindrical tubes between flat platens
Int J Impact Eng
Quasi-static axial and lateral crushing of radial corrugated composite tubes
Thin-Walled Struct
Crashworthiness of pre-impacted glass/epoxy composite tubes
Int J Impact Eng
Pipe stiffness prediction of buried GFRP flexible pipe
Polym Polym Compos
Flattening process of empty and polyurethane foam-filled E-glass/vinylester composite tubes – an experimental study
Compos Struct
Experimental investigation on the energy absorption and contact force of unstiffened and grid-stiffened composite cylindrical shells under lateral compression
Compos Struct
Geometrical discontinuities effects on lateral crushing and energy absorption of tubular structures
Mater Des
Investigation of free-spanned pipeline behavior due to axial forces and local loads
J Constr Steel Res
Behavior of pre-compressed tubes subjected to local loads
Ocean Eng
Thorough investigation of continuously supported pipelines under combined pre-compression and denting loads
Int J Press Vessel Pip
Free-spanning and base-supported tubes subjected to combined axial compression and indentation loads
J Constr Steel Res
Failure of a flexible pipe with a concrete liner
On the residual strength of aging cast iron trunk mains: physically-based models for asset failure
Mater Sci Eng A
Energy absorption capability of laterally loaded segmented composite tubes
Compos Struct
Lateral plastic collapse of sandwich tubes with metal foam core
Int J Mech Sci
A review of current development in natural fiber composites for structural and infrastructure applications
Natural materials
Mater Technol
Natural fibers, biopolymers, and biocomposites
Natural fiber polymer composites. Illustrate
Agenda 21 for sustainable construction in developing countries
Plant fibers as reinforcement for green composites
Tensile testing of cellulose based natural fibers for structural composite applications
J Compos Mater
Biofibres, biodegradable polymers and biocomposites: an overview
Macromol Mater Eng
Yuvraj Singh Negi. Recent development in natural fiber reinforced polypropylene composites
J Reinf Plast Compos
Compression behavior of concrete cylinders externally confined by flax fiber reinforced polymer sheets
Adv Struct Eng
Cited by (20)
Lateral crushing behavior of tubular lattice structures with triply periodic minimal surface architectures
2023, Thin-Walled StructuresIndentation and puncture response characteristics of flax fibre-reinforced polymer pipes
2022, Composites Part A: Applied Science and ManufacturingCitation Excerpt :Flax fibre-reinforced epoxy (FFRE) showed close similarity in specific tensile modulus to glass fibre-reinforced epoxy (GFRE) composites [1], and research on various structural components that were retrofitted with or manufactured from FFRE showed a substantial potential for the use of FFRE in the construction industry [5–7]. Whilst corrosion is considered a major issue that diminishes the service life of concrete and steel pipes [7], FFRE is corrosion-resistant and therefore a protective coating is not necessary for the corrosion-protection of FFRE pipes [8,9]. Plastic pipes are manufactured from non-sustainable sources.
Mechanical behavior of bamboo composite tubes under axial compression
2022, Construction and Building MaterialsExperimental study of flax fabric-reinforced epoxy pipes subjected to internal pressure
2021, Composites Part A: Applied Science and ManufacturingCitation Excerpt :The application of FFRE pipes features many advantages over the use of conventional pipe products, i.e. steel, asbestos and concrete pipes. Steel and concrete are vulnerable in corrosive conditions [3], while FFRE is corrosion-resistant [18,26], such that no specific protective coating is required for corrosion protection of the external and internal surfaces of FFRE pipes [19]. Although Polyvinyl chloride (PVC) pipes and glass fibre-reinforced thermosetting resin pipes (GFRP pipes) are corrosion resistant [18,19,27], these classes of pipes are produced from non-sustainable sources.