Abstract
The creation of protected conservation areas may result in protracted conflicts between stakeholders. In this study we examine the drivers of anthropogenic wildfire ignitions in the National Park of “los Alerces” (NPA) in Patagonia, Argentina. The NPA was established in 1937 to protect the native “andino-patagónico” forests from wildfires as well as preserving its scenic beauty and native flora and fauna. At the time of its creation state authorities prohibited all extractive human activities in the “intangible”—fully protected—“National Park” section, while other regulated extractive and ecotourism activities were allowed to continue in the “Natural Reserve” section in an effort to accommodate the historical entitlements of the displaced populations of “pobladores” (settlers) that had been living in the NPA for over a century. Here we interviewed the main stakeholder groups—“pobladores”, forest rangers and administrators, ecolodge owners and angler club members—to identify the drivers of wildfire ignitions in the park. Wildfires have been singled out by state authorities as the main threat to the NPA though considerable scientific uncertainty exists regarding their complex ecological effects. This study argues, based on the human and biophysical system data collected, that two conflicting cultural frames exist within the NPA that provide the necessary backdrop for understanding the drivers of wildfire ignitions. In turn, these findings raise puzzling dilemmas for the main theoretical approaches that have been used to inform and design conflict management strategies in protected conservation areas.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Ager A, Kline J, Paige-Fischer A (2015) Coupling the biophysical and social dimensions of wildfire risk to improve wildfire mitigation planning. Risk Anal 35(8):1393–1406
Agrawal A (2014) Studying the commons, governing common pool resource outcomes: some concluding thoughts. Environ Sci Policy 36:86–91
Arrigoni GI (2002) Los ceramistas prehistóricos del valle del río Desaguadero, Parque Nacional Los Alerces, provincia de Chubut. Relaciones XXVII: 395–412. Buenos Aires, Sociedad Argentina de Antropología
Barreda V, Anzóguetui LM, Prieto AR, Aceñolaza P, bianchi MM, Borromei AM, brea Mm Caccavari M, Cuadrado GA, Garralla S, Grill. Guerstein RG, Lutz AI, Manzini MV, Mautino LR, Ottone EG, Quattrocchio ME, Romero EJ, Zamaloa MC, Zucol A (2007) Diversificación y cambios de las angiospermas durante el Neógeno en Argentina. Asociación Paleontológica Argentina. Publicación especial 11 ISSN 0328-347X Ameghiniana 50° aniversario, Buenos Aires, Argentina, pp 173–191
Bengston D (1994) Changing forest values and ecosystem management. Soc Nat Resour 6(7):515–533
Bianchi LO, Defosse GE (2015) Live fuel moisture content and leaf ignition of forest species in Andean Patagonia, Argentina. International Journal of Wildland Fire. https://doi.org/10.1071/WF13099
Blackhall M, Raffaele E, Veblen T (2008) Cattle affect early post-fire regeneration in a Nothofagus dombeyi–Austrocedrus chilensis mixed forest in northern Patagonia, Argentina. Biol Conser 141(9):2251–2261
Boletin Oficial de la Republica Argentina (1937) https://www.boletinoficial.gob.ar/seccion/primera/19921216
Boletin Oficial de la Republica Argentina (1992) Seccion 1 Miercoles 16 diciembre: 3. https://www.boletinoficial.gob.ar/detalleAviso/primera/7132018/19921216
Brillinger DR (2010) Some examples of the communication of risk and uncertainty. Environmetrics 21:719–727. https://doi.org/10.1002/ENV.1040
Brockington et al. (2008) Unbound nature: conservation, capitalism and the future of protected areas. Earthscan, London
Carrier J, West P (2009) Virtualism, governance and practice: vision and execution in environmental conservation. Berghahn Books, New York
Castro A, Nielsen E (2003) Natural resource conflict management case studies: an analysis of power, participation and protected areas. FAO, Rome
CIEFAP; MAyDS (2016) http://ciefap.org.ar/
Cronon W (1996) Uncommon ground. Norton, New York
Defosse GE, Godoy MM, Bianchi LO, Lederer NS, Kunst C (2015) Fire history, fire ecology and management in Argentine Patagonia: from ancient times to nowadays. Chapter 7, In: Leblon B, Alexander ME (eds). Current International Perspectives on Wildland Fires, Mankind and the Environment. Nova Science Publishers, New York, pp 177–210
Defosse G, Sagarzazu MS, Godoy MM (2006) Incendios por rayos en los bosques andino patagónicos: Estudio de caso en el Parque Nacional los Alerces. Congreso; Segunda Reunión Patagonica y Tercera Nacional sobre Ecología y Manejo del Fuego: CIEFAP
Druckman J (2004) Political preference formation: competition, deliberation, and the (ir)relevance of framing effects. Am Political Sci Rev 98(4):671–686
Fiorentino R et al. (1995) Estudio de alternativas productivas para el desarrollo agropecuario de la zona cordillerana de la provincia del Chubut, Primera Parte., Gobierno del Chubut
Fischer AP, Spies TA, Steelman TA, Moseley C, Johnson BR, Bailey JD et al. (2016) Wildfire risk as a socioecological pathology. Front Ecol Environ 14(5):276–284
Fomin V, Mikhailovich A, Shiyatov S (2015) New approaches to studies on the dynamics of high-mountain tree vegetation using repeated landscape photographs: the example of the Polar Urals. Russian J Ecol 46(5):397–404
Gibson C, Koontz T (1999) When community is not enough: institutions and values in community based forest management in Southern Indiana. Hum Ecol 26(4):621–647
Gould P, White R (2012) Mental maps. Taylor and Francis, London
Gunckel LH (1948) La floración de la quila y del colihue en la Araucanía. Cienc e Investigación (Chile) 4:91–95
Hardin G (1968) The tragedy of the commons. Science 162:243–253
Hendrick L, Copenheaver C (2009) Using repeat landscape photography to assess vegetation changes in rural communities of the Southern Appalachian Mountains in Virginia, USA. Mt Res Dev 29(1):21–29
Holz A, Palma RE (2012) Floraciones de bambúes en Chile y Argentina: actual floración masiva del colihue, historia natural y riesgos asociados. Rev Bosque Nativ 50:40–46
Hosseus CK (1915) Las cañas de bambú en las cordilleras del sud. Boletín del Ministerio de. Agricultura (Rep.ública Argent) 19:195–208
Iglesias A, Artabe E, Morel EM (2011) The evolution of Patagonian climate and vegetation from the Mezozoic to the present. Boilogical J Linn Soc 103:409–422
Iriarte-Goñi M, Ayuda S (2018) Should forest transition theory include effects on forest fires? The case of Spain in the second half of the twentieth century. Land Use Policy 76:789–797
Ives C, Kendal D (2014) The role of social values in the management of ecological systems. J Environ Manag 144:67–72
Kitzberger T, Raffaele E, Veblen TT (2005) Variable community responses to herbivory in fire-altered landscapes of northern Patagonia, Argentina. Afr J Range Forage Sci 22(2):85–91
Kouthce V (1947) Informe Parque Nacional Los Alerces. Administración General Parques Nacionales y Turismo
KPMG (2016) La ganaderia y la industria de la carne bovina. https://assets.kpmg.com/content/dam/kpmg/pdf/2016/06/kpmg-argentina-la-ganaderia-y-la-industria-de-la-carne-bovina-enero-2016.pdf
Kull C (2005) Historical landscape repeat photography as a tool for land use change research. Norwegian J Geogr 59(4):253–268
Laris P, Wardell D (2006) Good, bad or ‘necessary evil’? Reinterpreting the colonial burning experiments in the savanna landscapes of West Africa. Geogr J 172(4):271–290
Lejano R, Fernandez de Castro F (2014) Norms, networks and commons: the invisible hand of community. Environ Sci Policy 36:73–85
Liu J, Dietz T, Carpenter S, Alberti M, Folke C, Moran E, Pell A, Deadman P, Kratz T, Lubchenco J, Ostrom E, Ouyang Z, Provencher W, Redman C, Schneider S, Taylor W (2007) Complexity of coupled human and naturalsystems. Science 317:1513–1516
Liu J, Ouyang Z, Miao H (2010) Environmental attitudes of stakeholders and their perceptions regarding protected area-community conflicts: a case study in China. J Environ Manag 91(11):2254–2262
Martinez L (2008) Evaluación del espacio para la ganadería extensiva sustentable y la conservación del Huemul (Hippocamelus bisulcus), en el Parque Nacional Los Alerces, Provincia de Chubut, Argentina. APRONA Bol Cient Nro 41:45–67
Mather A (1992) The forest transition. Area 24(4):367–379
Mather A (2001) Forests of consumption: postproductivism, postmaterialism and the postindustrial forest. Environ Plan C 19(2):249–268
Matteucci S, Tocino M, Aristide P (2016) Ecological and social consequences of the forest transition theory as applied to the Argentinean Great Chaco. Land Use Policy 51:8–17
McMillan D, Chavis D (1986) Sense of community: a definition and theory. J Community Psychol 14:6–23
Mermoz M, Kitzberger T, Veblen TT (2005) Landscape influences on occurrence and spread of wildfires in Patagonian forests and shrublands. Ecology 86(10):2705–2715
Meyfroidt P, Lambin E (2011) Global forest transition: prospects for an end to deforestation. Annu Rev Environ Resour 36:343–371
Milcu AI Hanspach J Abson D Fischer J (2013) Cultural ecosystem services: a literature review and prospects for future research. Ecol Soc18 (3). https://doi.org/10.5751/ES-05790-180344
Miller C, Ager A (2012) A review of recent advances in risk analysis for wildfire management. Int J Wildland Fire 22:1–14
Moglia JG, Giménez D (2002) Recomendaciones para la determinación, medición y recuento de anillos en especies del Chaco Seco. Revista de Ciencia y Técnica. UNSE. ISSN N° 0328-5928 N° 5.
Neumann R (2002) Imposing wilderness: struggles over livelihood and nature preservation in Africa. University of California Press, California
Neves EG, Petersen JB, Bartone RN, Heckenberger MJ (2004) The timing of terra preta formation in the central Amazon: archaeological data from three sites. In: Glaser B, Woods WI (eds). Amazonian dark earths: explorations in space and time. Springer, Berlin, Heidelberg
Oliveira T, Guiomar N, Baptista OF, Pereira JMC, Claro J (2017) Is Portugal's forest transition going up in smoke? Land Use Policy 66:214–226
Oriola J (2007) La experiencia frustrada de la cooperative Tambera Futaleufu Esquel Trevelin en Chubut 1970–1995. Observatorio Iberoamericano del Desarrollo Local y la Economía Social, http://www.hechohistorico.com.ar/Trabajos/Jornadas%20de%20Roca%20%202006/Oriola%20(La%20expewriencia).pdf
Ostrom E (1990) Governing the commons. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
Ostrom E (2005) Understanding institutional diversity. Princeton University Press, Princeton
Ostrom E (2008) A general framework for analyzing sustainability of social-ecological systems. Science 325(5939):419–422
Pearson AK, Pearson OP, Gómez IA (1994) Biology of the bamboo Chusquea culeou (Poaceae Bambusoidae) in Argentina. Vegetatio 111:93–126. Kluwer Academic Publishers, Belogium
Perz S (2007) Grand theory and context specificity in the study of forest dynamics: forest transition theory and other directions. Prof Geogr 59(1):105–114
Peterson R, Russell D, West P, Brosius J (2008) Seeing and doing conservation through cultural lenses. Environ Manag 1(45):5–18
Raymond C, Bryan B, MacDonald D, Cast A, Stratheam S, Grandgirard A, Kalivas T (2009) Mapping community values for natural capital and ecosystem services. Ecol Econ 68(5):1301–1315
Rhemtulla J, Hall R, Higgs E, Macdonald S (2002) Eighty years of change: vegetation in the montane ecoregion of Jasper National Park, Alberta, Canada. Can J For Res 32(11):2010–2021
Rudel T (1998) Is there a forest transition? Deforestation, reforestation and development. Rural Sociol 63(4):533–552
Rudel T, Coomes OT, Moran E, Achard F, Angelsen A, Xu J, Lambin E (2005) Forest transitions: towards a global understanding of land use change. Glob Environ Chang 15(1):23–31
Runte A (1979) National parks: the American experience. University of Nebraska Press, Lincoln
Scarzanella E (2002) Las bellezas naturales y la nacion: Los parques nacionales de Argentina en la primera mitad del siglo XX. Rev Europea de Estudios Latinoamericanos y del Caribe 73:5–21
Scholte S, Van Teeffelen A, Verburg P (2015) Integrating socio-cultural perspectivas into ecosystem services valuation: a review of concepts and methods. Ecol Econ 114:67–78
Scott J (1999) Seeing like a state. Yale University Press, New Haven
Seijo F (2009) Who framed the forest fire? State framing and peasant counter-framing of anthropogenic forest fires in Spain since 1940. J Environ Policy Plan 11:103–128
Seijo F, Cespedes B, Zavala G (2018) Traditional fire use impact in the aboveground carbon stock of the chestnut forests of Central Spain and its implications for prescribed burning. Sci Total Environ 625:1405–1414
Snow D, Rochford E, Worden S, Benford R (1986) Frame alignment processes, micromobilization, and movement participation. Am Sociol Rev 51:464–481
Spencer-Wood S (2010) Introduction to the historical archaeology of culturally powered landscapes. Int J Hist Archaeol 4(14):463–474
Stokes MAyTL, Smiley (1968) An introduction to tree ring dating. University of Chicago Press, Chicago, p 73
Tonnies F (1957) Community and society (C.P. Loomis, Ed. and Trans.). Harper Torchbook, New York
Tortorelli LA (1947) Los incendios de bosques en la Argentina. Ministerio deAgricultura de la Nación. Dirección Forestal. Repçublica Argentina, Buenos Aires
Veblen TT, Baker WL, Montenegro G, Swetnam TW (eds) (2003) Fire and climatic change in temperate ecosystems of the Western Americas. In: Ecological studies (analysis and synthesis), vol 160. Springer, New York, NY
Veblen TT (1982) Growth-patterns of Chusquea bamboos in the understory of Chilean Nothofagus forests and their influences in forest dynamics. Bull Torrey Bot Club 109:474–487
Veblen TT, Kitzberger T, Raffaele E, Mermoz M, Gonzalez M, Sibold J, Holz A (2009) The historical range of variability of fires in the Andean-Patagonian Nothofagus forest region. Int J Wildland Fire 17(6):724–741
Vila A, Borrelli L (2011) Cattle in the Patagonian forests: feeding ecology in Los Alerces National Reserve. For Ecol Manag 261(7):1306–1314
Walker R, Smith T (1993) Tropical deforestation and forest management under the system of concession logging: a decision-theoretic analysis. J Reg Sci 33(3):387–419
West P, Igoe J, Brockington D (2006) Parks and peoples: the social impact of protected areas. Annu Rev Anthropol 35:251–277
Wilhelm EJ Jr, (1968) Fire ecology of the Valdivian rain forest. In: Proceedings of the 8th Tall Timbers Fire Ecology Conference, Tallahasse, FL, pp 55–70
Wright S, Muller-Landau H (2006) The future of tropical forest species. Biotropica 38(3):287–301
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Ethics declarations
Conflict of interest
The authors declare that they have no conflict of interest.
Additional information
Publisher’s note Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Supplementary material
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Seijo, F., Godoy, M.M., Guglielmin, D. et al. Conflicting Frames about Ownership and Land Use Drive Wildfire Ignitions in a Protected Conservation Area. Environmental Management 65, 448–462 (2020). https://doi.org/10.1007/s00267-020-01265-w
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00267-020-01265-w