Abstract
eLearning systems have become a very important part of teaching, both as web-based systems for online education and as auxiliary tools for face-to-face study, where they provide an additional learning support for on-campus learners. To insure the sustainability of an eLearning system on both individual and social levels, we have to cover many aspects of sustainability requirements: human, technical, economic, and environmental. This paper provides a systematic literature review of the sustainability meta-requirements for eLearning systems to identify open problems and to present the state of the art of this research area. We analysed 124 papers, so we identified 18 high-level sustainability requirements for eLearning systems.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Allen DB, Gould RA, Littrell LA, Schillie JE (2010) K-state’s distributed learning commons: achieving long-term sustainability through strategic partnerships. Coll. Undergrad. Libr. 17(2):160–176
Alrashidi A (2013) An exploration of e-learning benefits for Saudi Arabia: Toward policy reform. PhD thesis, University of La Verne
Amador F, Oliveira CP (2013) Integrating sustainability into the university: past, present, and future. In: Sustainability assessment tools in higher education institutions: mapping trends and good practices around the world, Springer, pp 65–78
Anderson T, Dron J (2012) Learning technology through three generations of technology enhanced distance education pedagogy. Eur J Open Distance e-learn 15(2):1–14
Assembly UG (2015) Transforming our world: the 2030 agenda for sustainable development. Technical report, A/RES/70/1, 21 October
Attwell G (2007) Personal learning environments-the future of e-learning? eLearning Pap 2(1):1–8
Bell M, Bell W (2005) It’s installed... now get on with it! looking beyond the software to the cultural change. Br J Educ Technol 36(4):643–656
Bensch S, Rager M (2012) Cloud-based online learning platforms. In: Business information systems workshops, vol 127 LNBIP, pp 165–176
Berge ZL, Giles L (2006) Implementing and sustaining e-learning in the workplace. Int J Inf Commun Technol Educ (IJICTE) 2(4):64–75
Berge ZL, Giles L (2008) Strategic planning for e-learning in the workplace. In: Adapting information and communication technologies for effective education. IGI Global, pp 257–270
Berkhout F, Hertin J (2001) Impacts of information and communication technologies on environmental sustainability: speculations and evidence. Report to the OECD, Brighton, p 21
Betz S, Caporale T (2014) Sustainable software system engineering. In: The fourth international conference on big data and cloud computing (BdCloud). IEEE, pp 612–619
Bhat JS (2011) Technological ambidexterity in the management of national infrastructure programmes. J Asian Public Policy 4(3):350–356
Bottino RM (2007) On-line learning networks: framework and scenarios. Educ Inf Technol 12(2):93–105
Bourn D, Shiel C (2009) Global perspectives: aligning agendas? Environ Educ Res 15(6):661–677
Brereton P, Kitchenham BA, Budgen D, Turner M, Khalil M (2007) Lessons from applying the systematic literature review process within the software engineering domain. J Syst Softw 80(4):571–583
Breslow L, Pritchard DE, DeBoer J, Stump GS, Ho AD, Seaton DT (2013) Studying learning in the worldwide classroom: research into edx’s first mooc. Res Pract Asses 8:13–25
Buchan J (2010) Putting ourselves in the big picture: a sustainable approach to project management for e-learning. Int J E-Learn Distance Educ 24(1):55–76
Burton SL, Harris HR, Burrell DN, Brown-Jackson KL, Bessette D, McClintock R, Lu S, White YW (2014) Educational edifices need a mobile strategy to fully engage in learning activities. In: Implications of social media use in personal and professional settings, pp 284–309
Calero C, Piattini M (2015) Green in software engineering. Springer, Berlin
Calero C, Piattini M (2017) Puzzling out software sustainability. Sustain Comput Inf Syst 16:117–124
Calero C, Bertoa MF, Moraga MÁ (2013) Sustainability and quality: icing on the cake. In: Proceedings of the 2nd international workshop on requirements engineering for sustainable systems, CEUR-WS.org
Cápay M, Mesárošová M, Balogh Z (2011) Analysis of students’ behaviour in e-learning system. In: Proceedings of the 22nd EAEEIE annual conference (EAEEIE), 2011. IEEE, pp 1–6
Casquero O, Portillo J, Ovelar R, Benito M, Romo J (2010) iPLE network: an integrated eLearning 2.0 architecture from a university’s perspective. Interact Learn Environ 18(3):293–308
Castro-Schez JJ, Redondo MA, Gallardo J, Jurado F et al (2012) Designing and developing software for educative virtual laboratories with language processing techniques: lessons learned in practical experiments. J Res Pract Inf Technol 44(3):289–308
Chang V, Guetl C (2007) E-learning ecosystem (eles)-a holistic approach for the development of more effective learning environment for small-and-medium sized enterprises (SMES). In: Digital EcoSystems and technologies conference, 2007. DEST’07. Inaugural IEEE-IES. IEEE, pp 420–425
Chen CM, Lee HM, Chen YH (2005) Personalized e-learning system using item response theory. Comput Educ 44(3):237–255
Chen IY (2007) The factors influencing members’ continuance intentions in professional virtual communitiesa longitudinal study. J Inf Sci 33(4):451–467
Cheung CM, Lee MK (2009) Understanding the sustainability of a virtual community: model development and empirical test. J Inf Sci 35(3):279–298
Chiu CM, Hsu MH, Wang ET (2006) Understanding knowledge sharing in virtual communities: an integration of social capital and social cognitive theories. Decis Supp Syst 42(3):1872–1888
Colasante M (2010) Future-focused learning via online anchored discussion, connecting learners with digital artefacts, other learners, and teachers. In: Ascilite 2010. Ascilite, pp 211–221
Colomo-Palacios R, Messnarz R, Siakas K, Palosi D, Coakley D (2014) Using social media as a tool for business improvement and certification of knowledge workers. J Softw Evol Process 26(9):791–798
Dagger D, Conlan O, Wade V (2005) Fundamental requirements of personalised elearning development environments. In: Richards G (ed) E-Learn: world conference on e-learning in corporate, government, healthcare, and higher education 2005, association for the advancement of computing in education (AACE), pp 2746–2754
Dagger D, O’Connor A, Lawless S, Walsh E, Wade V (2007) Service-oriented e-learning platforms: from monolithic systems to flexible services. Internet Comput 11(3):28–35
Demirkan H, Goul M, Gros M (2010) A reference model for sustainable e-learning service systems: experiences with the joint university/teradata consortium. Decis Sci J Innov Educ 8(1):151–189
Demski J (2012) Rebuilding the lms for the 21st century. Campus Technol 25(8):34
Dholakia U, King J, Baraniuk R (2006) What makes an open education program sustainable? the case of connexions. In: Open education conference, vol 2340
Dinevski D (2008) Open educational resources and lifelong learning. In: 30th international conference on information technology interfaces ITI 2008, 2008. IEEE, pp 117–122
Dong B, Zheng Q, Yang J, Li H, Qiao M (2009) An e-learning ecosystem based on cloud computing infrastructure. In: International conference on advanced learning technologies. IEEE, pp 125–127
Downes S (2007) Models for sustainable open educational resources. Interdiscip J E-Learn Learn Objects 3(1):29–44
Dyson LE, Litchfield A, Lawrence E, Raban R, Leijdekkers P (2009) Advancing the m-learning research agenda for active, experiential learning: four case studies. Aust J Educ Technol 25(2):250–267
Ellis RA (2016) Students approaches to groupwork in a blended course, associations with perceptions of the online environment and academic achievement-when is learning engaged? Educ Inf Technol 21(5):1095–1112
Farooq U, Schank P, Harris A, Fusco J, Schlager M (2007) Sustaining a community computing infrastructure for online teacher professional development: a case study of designing tapped in. Comput Support Cooper Work (CSCW) 16(4–5):397–429
Fisler J, Bleisch S (2006) elml, the elesson markup language: developing ustainable e-learning content using an open source xml framework. In: In WEBIST 2006-international conference on web information systems and technologies, 11th–13th April 2006 (Setubal, Citeseer)
Fisler J, Schneider F (2009) Creating, handling and implementing e-learning courses using the open source tools olat and elml at the university of zurich. In: Proceedings of the world congress on engineering and computer science, vol 1
Franceschi KG, Lee RM, Hinds D (2008) Engaging e-learning in virtual worlds: supporting group collaboration. In: Proceedings of the 41st annual Hawaii international conference on system sciences. IEEE, pp 7–7
Friesen N (2009) Open educational resources: New possibilities for change and sustainability. Int Rev Res Open Distrib Learn 10(5):1–13
Garg K, Varma V (2015) Systemic requirements of a software engineering learning environment. In: Proceedings of the 8th India software engineering conference, ISEC ’15. ACM, pp 147–155
Garrison DR, Akyol Z (2009) Role of instructional technology in the transformation of higher education. J Comput Higher Educ 21(1):19
Georgiadou E, Siakas KV (2006) Distance learning: technologies; enabling learning at own place, own pace, own time. In: Proceedings of the 11th international conference on software process improvement-research into education and training,(INSPIRE 2006) learning and teaching issues in software quality, April, Southampton, UK, pp 29–40
Ghirardini B (2011) E-learning methodologies A guide for designing and developing e-learning courses. Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations
Goodland R (2002) The concept of environmental sustainability. Annu Rev Ecol Syst 26(1):1–24
Gunn C (2010) Sustainability factors for e-learning initiatives. ALT-J 18(2):89–103
Gunn C (2011) Sustaining e-learning innovations, changing demands, changing directions. Proc Ascilite Hobart 2011:509–519
Gunn C, Woodgate S, OGrady W (2005) Repurposing learning objects: a sustainable alternative? ALT-J 13(3):189–200
Gustavsson I, Nilsson K, Zackrisson J, Garcia-Zubia J, Hernandez-Jayo U, Nafalski A, Nedic Z, Gol O, Machotka J, Pettersson M, Lago T, Hkansson L (2009) On objectives of instructional laboratories, individual assessment, and use of collaborative remote laboratories. IEEE Trans Learn Technol 2(4):263–274
Halimi S (2005) Lifelong learning for equity and social cohesion: a new challenge for higher education. Lifelong Learn Distance Higher Educ Commonw Learn /UNESCO 2005:11–22
Halkias D, Mills GT (2008) Distance education in support of lifelong learning: the case of the hellas alive web platform in building greek language learning communities. In: Proceedings of the 12th international conference on computers. ACM, pp 57–60
Hine N, Petersen F, Pluke M, Sund T (2008) Standardization work on personalized ehealth systems. In: Proceedings of the 30th annual international conference of the IEEE engineering in medicine and biology society. IEEE, pp 1518–1520
Hoffman JJ, Hoelscher ML, Sherif K (2005) Social capital, knowledge management, and sustained superior performance. J Knowl Manag 9(3):93–100
Hylén J (2006) Open educational resources: opportunities and challenges. In: Proceedings of open education
Iatagan M (2012) Strategies for ongoing professional training of human resources in a globalized economy. Human Capital and Resources: Developments, Management and Strategies
ISO/IEC 25010 (2011) Systems and software engineering software product quality requirements and evaluation (square) software product quality and system quality in use models
James P (2014) Urban sustainability in theory and practice: circles of sustainability. Routledge, London
Jiang H, Ganoe C, Carroll JM (2010) Four requirements for digital case study libraries. Educ Inf Technol 15(3):219–236
Jin G, Law R (2009) Lifelong learning to advance the engineer’s career. Ann Conf Can Soc Civil Eng 1:50–59
Kazancoglu Y, Aksoy M (2011) A fuzzy logic-based qfd to identify key factors of e-learning design. Proc Soc Beha Sci 28:322–327
Keele S (2007) Guidelines for performing systematic literature reviews in software engineering. Technical report, Department of Computer Science, University of Durham
Keengwe J, Malapile S (2014) Factors influencing technology planning in developing countries: a literature review. Educ Inf Technol 19(4):703–712
Kendall M (2005) Lifelong learning really matters for elementary education in the 21st century. Educ Inf Technol 10(3):289–296
Kim P, Miranda T, Olaciregui C (2008) Pocket school: exploring mobile technology as a sustainable literacy education option for underserved indigenous children in latin america. Int J Educ Dev 28(4):435–445
Kitchenham B, Dyba T, Jorgensen M (2004) Evidence-based software engineering. In: 26th International conference on software engineering. ACM, pp 273–281
Ko HM (2012) Soft power: a critical factor for the effectiveness and development of a school. Lecture Notes in Computer Science (including subseries Lecture Notes in Artificial Intelligence and Lecture Notes in Bioinformatics) 7513 LNCS:414–420
Koçak SA, Alptekin GI, Bener AB (2015) Integrating environmental sustainability in software product quality. In: Proceedings of the fourth international workshop on requirements engineering for sustainable systems (RE4SuSy), CEUR-WS.org, pp 17–24
Konting MM (2012) Leadership development for sustainability of e-learning. Proc Soc Beh Sci 67:312–321
Koohang A, Harman K (2007) Advancing sustainability of open educational resources. Issues Inf Sci Inf Technol 4:535–544
Koshkin AP, Rassolov IM, Novikov AV (2016) Monitoring social media: students satisfaction with university administration activities. Educ Inf Technol 22:2499–2522
Kruchten P (2015) Lifelong learning for lifelong employment. IEEE Softw 32(4):85–87
Kumar S, Buyya R (2012) Green cloud computing and environmental sustainability. Harnessing green it: principles and practices, pp 315–339
Lago P, Jansen T (2011) Creating environmental awareness in service oriented software engineering. In: Service-oriented computing. Springer, pp 181–186
Lago P, Koçak SA, Crnkovic I, Penzenstadler B (2015) Framing sustainability as a property of software quality. Commun ACM 58(10):70–78
van Lamsweerde A (2008) Requirements engineering: From craft to discipline. In: Proceedings of the 16th ACM SIGSOFT international symposium on foundations of software engineering. ACM, pp 238–249
Laurillard D (2007) Modelling benefits-oriented costs for technology enhanced learning. Higher Educ 54(1):21–39
Lee MJ, Chan A (2007) Pervasive, lifestyle-integrated mobile learning for distance learners: an analysis and unexpected results from a podcasting study. Open Learn 22(3):201–218
Littlejohn A (2003a) Reusing online resources: a sustainable approach to e-learning. Psychology Press, London
Littlejohn A (2003b) Supporting sustainable e-learning. Assoc Learn Technol J 11(3):88–102
Liu CC, Chung CW, Tao SY (2009) Making classrooms socio-technical environments for supporting collaborative learning: the role of personal devices and boundary objects. In: Proceedings of the 9th international conference on computer supported collaborative learning, international society of the learning sciences, CSCL’09, pp 320–324
Lizhong T, Aichen Z, Yongjie S (2011) The function of the university libraries in constructing lifelong education system. Adv Intell Soft Comput 109:341–346
Mahmood T, Hafeez K (2013) Performance assessment of an e-learning software system for sustainability. Int J Qual Serv Sci 5(2):208–229
Mahmoud SS, Ahmad I (2013) A green model for sustainable software engineering. Int J Softw Eng Appl 7(4):1738–9984
Manca S, Ranieri M (2017) Implications of social network sites for teaching and learning. Where we are and where we want to go. Educ Inf Technol 22(2):605–622
Manuja M, et al (2011) Industry academia collaboration model: the design challenges. In: 2011 24th IEEE-CS Conference on software engineering education and training (CSEE&T). IEEE, pp 111–120
Mason M (2008) What is complexity theory and what are its implications for educational change? Educ Philos Theory 40(1):35–49
Memmel M (2011) Interoperability requirements for a sustainable component to support management and sharing of digital resources. In: 1st Workshop on exploring fitness and evolvability of personal learning environments, CEUR-WS.org, pp 25–29
Meneses G (2011) Design of an electronic instrumentation virtual laboratory based on free-open resources. In: 2011 6th Colombian computing congress (CCC). IEEE, pp 1–6
Miliszewska I, Sztendur E (2011) Critical success attributes of transnational it education programmes: the client perspective. J Inf Technol Educ Res 10(1):123–137
Mocigemba D (2006) Sustainable computing. Poiesis Praxis 4(3):163–184
Mohan L, Raman P, Choppella V, Reddy YR (2017) A crowdsourcing approach for quality enhancement of elearning systems. In: Proceedings of the 10th innovations in software engineering conference, ISEC ’17, ACM, pp 188–194
Motiwalla LF (2007) Mobile learning: a framework and evaluation. Comput Educ 49(3):581–596
Mridha GMN, Erlandsson B, Khan A, Islam M, Sultana N, Reza S, Srinivas M (2013) E-learning for empowering the rural people in bangladesh opportunities and challenges. In: International conference on e-learning and e-technologies in education (ICEEE). IEEE, pp 323–328
Müller J, Gil JMS, Hernández F, Giró X, Bosco A (2007) The socio-economic dimensions of ict-driven educational change. Comput Educ 49(4):1175–1188
Müller M, Siebenhüner B (2007) Policy instruments for sustainability-oriented organizational learning. Bus Strategy Environ 16(3):232–245
Naumann S, Dick M, Kern E, Johann T (2011) The GREENSOFT model: a reference model for green and sustainable software and its engineering. Sustain Comput Inform Syst 1(4):294–304
Neila R, Rabai LBA (2014) Deploying suitable countermeasures to solve the security problems within an e-learning environment. In: Proceedings of the 7th international conference on security of information and networks, SIN ’14, ACM, pp 33–38
Nichols M (2008) Institutional perspectives: the challenges of e-learning diffusion. Br J Educ Technol 39(4):598–609
Nunes EP, Luz AR, Lemos EM, Maciel C, dos Anjos AM, Borges LC, Nunes C (2016) Mobile serious game proposal for environmental awareness of children. In: The frontiers in education conference (FIE), IEEE, pp 1–8
Nwokediuko A (2012) Advancing e-learning in african native communities: the language factor. In: International conference on education and e-learning innovations (ICEELI). IEEE, pp 1–4
Olofsson AD, Lindberg JO (2006) ”Whatever happened to the social dimension?” aspects of learning in a distance-based teacher training programme. Educ Inf Technol 11(1):7–20
O’Neil AF (2008) The current status of instructional design theories in relation to today’s authoring systems. Br J Educ Technol 39(2):251–267
Ossiannilsson E, Landgren L (2012) Quality in e-learning-a conceptual framework based on experiences from three international benchmarking projects. J Comput Assist Learn 28(1):42–51
Pardo A, Fisteus JA, Kloos CD et al (2012) A distributed collaborative system for flexible learning content production and management. J Res Pract Inf Technol 44(2):203–221
Park CB, Choi H, Kim P (2009) Adaptive open mobile learning device for the underserved. In: ICCE’09 international conference on consumer electronics, digest of technical papers, IEEE
Pellas N (2014) The influence of computer self-efficacy, metacognitive self-regulation and self-esteem on student engagement in online learning programs: Evidence from the virtual world of second life. Comput Hum Behav 35:157–170. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.chb.2014.02.048
Pellas N (2016) Bolstering the quality and integrity of online collaborative university- level courses via an open sim standalone server in conjunction with sloodle. Educ Inf Technol 21(5):1007–1032
Penzenstadler B (2014) Infusing green: Requirements engineering for green in and through software systems. In: Proceedings of the third international workshop on requirements engineering for sustainable systems, (RE4SuSy), CEUR-WS.org
Penzenstadler B, Femmer H (2013) A generic model for sustainability with process- and product-specific instances. In: Proceedings of the workshop on green in/by software engineering. ACM, pp 3–8
Pettersson O, Vogel B (2012) Reusability and interoperability in mobile learning: a study of current practices. In: The seventh international conference on wireless. Mobile and ubiquitous technology in education. IEEE, pp 306–310
Pullen JM, Snow C (2007) Integrating synchronous and asynchronous internet distributed education for maximum effectiveness. Educ Inf Technol 12(3):137–148
Rahanu H, Georgiadou E, Siakas K, Ekert D, Messanarz R, Abeysinghe G (2015) Towards relating delivery methods and examination success: lessons learned from the valo llp project case study. J Softw Evol Process 27(8):555–564
Rajasingham L (2011) Will mobile learning bring a paradigm shift in higher education? Educ Res Int 2011:1–10. https://doi.org/10.1155/2011/5284951
Randelin M, Saaranen T, Naumanen P, Louhevaara V (2013) Towards sustainable well-being in smes through the web-based learning program of ergonomics. Educ Inf Technol 18(1):95–111
Razavian M, Procaccianti G, Tamburri DA, et al (2014) Four-dimensional sustainable e-services. In: Proceedings of the 28th EnviroInfo, Shaker-Verlag AG
Richey RC (2008) Reflections on the 2008 AECT definitions of the field. TechTrends 52(1):24–25
Robertson I (2008) Sustainable e-learning, activity theory and professional development. In: Ascilite, ASCILITE (Melbourne, Australia), pp 819–826
Roher K, Richardson D (2013) Sustainability requirement patterns. In: The third international workshop on requirements patterns (RePa). IEEE, pp 8–11
Rovai AP, Downey JR (2010) Why some distance education programs fail while others succeed in a global environment. Internet Higher Educ 13(3):141–147
Roy A (2012) eLearning: tool to ensure growth and sustainability of SMEs. In: Proceedings of the 11th European conference on e-learning. ECEL, p 480
Roy R, Potter S, Yarrow K (2008) Designing low carbon higher education systems: environmental impacts of campus and distance learning systems. Int J Sustain Higher Educ 9(2):116–130
Ruyters M, Colasante M, Douglas K, Mandarano G (2012) Sustainability of a university designed and developed media annotation tool to prepare learners with skills needed for future employment. ASCILITE–annual conference of the Australian Society for Computers in Tertiary Education
Salmon G (2005) Flying not flapping: a strategic framework for e-learning and pedagogical innovation in higher education institutions. ALT-J 13(3):201–218
Schoenwald I (2003) Sustainable implementation of e-learning as a change process at universities. Online Educ 1:1–6
Scoppio G, Luyt I (2017) Mind the gap: enabling online faculty and instructional designers in mapping new models for quality online courses. Educ Inf Technol 22:725–746
Secundo G, Passiante G, Romano A (2012) Industry-university learning network to create competences for intelligent and sustainable manufacturing: a case study. In: International conference on information technology based higher education and training (ITHET). IEEE, pp 1–8
Secundo G, Passiante G, Romano A, Moliterni P (2013) Developing the next generation of engineers for intelligent and sustainable manufacturing: a case study. Int J Eng Educ 29(1):248–262
Sharpe R, Benfield G, Francis R (2006) Implementing a university e-learning strategy: levers for change within academic schools. Res Learn Technol 14(2):135–151
Shehabat IM, Mahdi SA (2009) E-learning and its impact to the educational system in the arab world. In: International conference on information management and engineering. IEEE, pp 220–225
Shen L, LeClair J (2013) Use of sustainable and systematic plan to assess student learning outcomes for non-traditional it students. In: ASEE annual conference and exposition, American Society for Engineering Education
Sousa JL (2011) Information systems architecture modeling based on loosely coupled structures: an e-learning use case. In: 9th International conference on emerging elearning technologies and applications (ICETA). IEEE, pp 195–198
Sowe SK, Zettsu K, Murakami Y (2013) A model for creating and sustaining information services platform communities: lessons learnt from open source software. In: Proceedings of ITU kaleidoscope: building sustainable communities (K-2013). IEEE, pp 1–8
Sridharan B, Deng H, Corbitt B (2010) Critical success factors in elearning ecosystems: a qualitative study. J Syst Inf Technol 12(4):263–288
Stechert P (2006) Informatics system comprehension: a learner-centred cognitive approach to networked thinking. Educ Inf Technol 11(3):305–318
Stefanovic M (2013) The objectives, architectures and effects of distance learning laboratories for industrial engineering education. Comput Educ 69:250–262
Stepanyan K, Littlejohn A, Margaryan A (2013) Sustainable e-learning: toward a coherent body of knowledge. J Educ Technol Soc 16(2):91–102
Stewart B, Khare A (2012) Athabasca university reduces ict carbon footprint. GSTF J Comput 1(4):70–75
Stewart B, Khare A (2015) elearning and the sustainable campus. In: Transformative approaches to sustainable development at universities. Springer, pp 291–305
Stiles M, Yorke J (2007) Technology supported learning tensions between innovation, and control and organisational and professional cultures. J Organ Transform Soc Change 3(3):251–267
Suhonen J, Sutinen E (2014) The four pillar model-analysing the sustainability of online doctoral programmes. TechTrends 58(4):81–88
Sun PC, Tsai RJ, Finger G, Chen YY, Yeh D (2008) What drives a successful e-learning? an empirical investigation of the critical factors influencing learner satisfaction. Comput Educ 50(4):1183–1202
Thomas L, Trapp S (2007) Building re-configurable blendedlearning arrangements. In: Balkan conference in informatics (BCI 2007), pp 271–280
Tikhomirova N, Tikhomirov V, Maksimova V, Telnov Y (2012) Knowledge management in the smart university. Proc Eur Conf Knowl Manag 2:1172–1178
Tomkinson B, Hutt I (2012) Online pbl: a route to sustainability education? Campus-Wide Inf Syst 29(4):291–303
Toppin IN, Toppin SM (2016) Virtual schools: the changing landscape of k-12 education in the us. Educ Inf Technol 21(6):1571–1581
Törngren M, Bensalem S, McDermid J, Passerone R, Sangiovanni-Vincentelli A, Schätz B (2015) Education and training challenges in the era of cyber-physical systems: beyond traditional engineering. In: Proceedings of the WESE’15: workshop on embedded and cyber-physical systems education, WESE’15. ACM. pp 8:1–8:5
Trajkovik V, Caporali E, Palmisano E, Valdiserri J (2010) Establishing a videoconferencing infrastructure in the republic of macedonia as an engineering educational service. In: Joint International IGIP-SEFI annual conference, SEFI
Tuparov G, Kostadinova H, Tuparova D, Raykova M (2014) Approaches for competencies assessment in open source e-learning environments. In: Global engineering education conference (EDUCON). IEEE, pp 529–532
Uden L, Wangsa IT, Damiani E (2007) The future of e-learning: E-learning ecosystem. In: 2007 Inaugural IEEE-IES Digital EcoSystems and technologies conference, pp 113–117. https://doi.org/10.1109/DEST.2007.371955
Vogel B, Kurti A, Milrad M, Johansson E, Müller M (2014) Mobile inquiry learning in sweden: development insights on interoperability, extensibility and sustainability of the LETS GO software system. Educ Technol Soc 17(2):43–57
Vovides Y, Chale SB, Gadhula R, Kebaetse MB, Nigussie NA, Suleman F, Tibyampansha D, Ibrahim GR, Ntabaye M, Frehywot S et al (2014) A systems approach to implementation of elearning in medical education: five mepi schools’ journeys. Acad Med 89(8):S102–S106
Wang R, Scown P, Urquhart C, Hardman J (2014) Tapping the educational potential of facebook: guidelines for use in higher education. Educ Inf Technol 19(1):21–39
Weichhart G (2015) Supporting the evolution and interoperability of organisational models with e-learning technologies. Ann Rev Control 39:118–127
Winfree T, Goldacre P, Sherkat M, Graham P, Mendoza A, Miller T (2017) Learning for low carbon living: the potential of mobile learning applications for built environment trades and professionals in Australia. Proc Eng 180:1773–1783
Wohlin C (2014) Guidelines for snowballing in systematic literature studies and a replication in software engineering. In: Proceedings of the 18th international conference on evaluation and assessment in software engineering, EASE ’14. ACM, pp 38:1–38:10
Wohlin C, Runeson P, Höst M, Ohlsson MC, Regnell B (2012) Experimentation in software engineering. Springer, Berlin
Yigit T, Isik AH, Ince M (2014) Web-based learning object selection software using analytical hierarchy process. Softw IET 8(4):174–183
Zheng Q, He H, Ma T, Xue N, Li B, Dong B (2014) Big log analysis for e-learning ecosystem. In: The 11th international conference on e-business engineering. IEEE, pp 258–263
Zon G, Corrigan S, McDonald N, Maij A (2012) A learning, training & mentoring framework (ltm) & the role of serious games to facilitate sustainable change in the aviation industry. In: 11th International probabilistic safety assessment and management conference and the annual european safety and reliability conference, vol 6, pp 5044–5051
Acknowledgements
Ahmed D. Alharthi is supported by a scholarship from Umm Al-Qura University, Saudi Arabia.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Appendix
Appendix
See Table 5.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Alharthi, A.D., Spichkova, M. & Hamilton, M. Sustainability requirements for eLearning systems: a systematic literature review and analysis. Requirements Eng 24, 523–543 (2019). https://doi.org/10.1007/s00766-018-0299-9
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00766-018-0299-9