Trends in Genetics
ReviewFlipping Shells! Unwinding LR Asymmetry in Mirror-Image Molluscs
Section snippets
The Establishment of LR Asymmetry
While most animal bodies are bilaterally symmetric on the outside, the internal organs usually show a consistent LR asymmetry (see Glossary). Defining this LR asymmetry is a critical part of early development, such that left/right positional errors are an important class of human birth defects and, in later life, numerous diseases affect apparently symmetric organs in an asymmetric fashion [2., 3., 4.]. Yet, while a wealth of studies have been important in revealing the genes that promote the
A Twisted History of Embryology and Genetics in Snails
It has long been known that the direction of the chiral twist that takes place during the third cleavage corresponds to the shell coiling direction and body asymmetry of the adult snail [22]. During the early days of Mendelian genetics, Boycott and Diver [23] reported that shell coiling in the pond snail Lymnaea (Radix) peregra was a hereditary character, although the pattern of inheritance was difficult to understand. Sturtevant [24] responded and suggested that chirality is an exceptionally
Unwinding Snail Chirality
In an initially surprising finding (Box 2), it was discovered that at least two genes, including the TGF-β gene nodal, are involved in LR signalling in both vertebrate (Deuterostomia) and molluscan (Lophotrochozoa) asymmetry, yet are absent in derived animals, such as nematodes and fruit flies (Ecdysozoa) [5]. Then, it was shown that asymmetry in snails has much in common with other taxa that lack nodal. Thus, while the unequivocally first symmetry-breaking event in nematodes and snails is
Defining LR Asymmetry in the Cytoskeleton
Until recently, the means by which interacting sets of actin assembly factors work together in cells had remained obscure. This is unfortunate because a basic understanding of actin dynamics is a prerequisite for understanding how molecular chirality defines cellular chirality in snails.
One point of progress has been in understanding how cellular chirality arises from the self-organisation of the actin cytoskeleton (reviewed in [14,46]), and biomechanical forces in general [15]. By studying
From Chiral Cells to Chiral Shells
How is chirality transmitted from molecules to cells? Studies in the nematode have shown that the clockwise tilt of two blastomeres at the four–six cell-stage transition, which marks the initiation of LR asymmetry, is matched by counter-rotating chiral cortical flows along the divisional axes. Changing the flow speed changes the degree of blastomere rotation, indicating that intracellular chiral flow is directing symmetry breaking [63]. More generally, there is an increasing focus on LR
How Do Snails Commonly Vary in Their LR Asymmetry?
I began by highlighting the irony that molluscs, mainly snails, are the only animal group to vary in their LR asymmetry, yet many scientists are welded to studying invariant model species, mostly vertebrates, flies, or nematodes. More specifically, the invariant LR asymmetry of other spiralian phyla is rarely considered against the varying LR asymmetry of snails, despite fundamental similarities in their development [75]. There is an apparent paradox. Sinistral species of snails have evolved
Flipping Shells
A hypothesis is that snails vary in their chirality because of the combined effect of natural selection on the outward phenotype and the dichotomous switch of spiral cleavage during early development (Figure 3). Thus, while a body of research shows that the LR asymmetry is coded in the single-cell embryo, the twist of the third cleavage is the key moment that defines morphological body asymmetry. It is a dichotomous chiral switch that cannot be supressed by other pathways or redundancies [32,85
Concluding Remarks and Future Perspectives
Unlike any other animal group, snails commonly vary in their LR asymmetry. Although recent progress has implicated the cytoskeleton as key, the set of genes that determine chiral change are not known, nor how this is possible without pathology (see Outstanding Questions). I argue that constraints to chiral change are likely the default in all animals, except in snails, where new chiral variants can sometimes be favoured. This may be enabled by the dichotomous nature of spiralian cleavage and
Acknowledgements
I would like to thank Cristina Grande, Michael Levin, Menno Schilthuizen, Sundar Naganathan, Stéphane Noselli, Naoki Watanabe, and two anonymous referees for enjoyable discussions, and comments on the manuscript, and to Ken Hayes and Norine Yeung, for enabling field work.
Glossary
- Chiral
- an object that is asymmetric in such a way such that it is nonsuperimposable on its mirror image. A cell may have radial symmetry, by gross morphology, but contain a chiral cytoskeleton. A snail shell has LR asymmetry and is also chiral.
- Cytoskeleton
- the scaffolding of a cell, involving a network of protein filaments and microtubules in the cytoplasm that control cell shape, maintain intracellular organisation, and are involved in cell movement.
- Dextral or sinistral
- in this context, whether
References (100)
- et al.
A unified model for left-right asymmetry? Comparison and synthesis of molecular models of embryonic laterality
Dev. Biol.
(2013) Formin is associated with left-right asymmetry in the pond snail and the frog
Curr. Biol.
(2016)Body handedness is directed by genetically determined cytoskeletal dynamics in the early embryo
Curr. Biol.
(2004)Actomyosin-driven left-right asymmetry: from molecular torques to chiral self organization
Curr. Opin. Cell Biol.
(2016)- et al.
The balancing roles of mechanical forces during left-right patterning and asymmetric morphogenesis
Mech. Dev.
(2017) - et al.
Left–right patterning: breaking symmetry to asymmetric morphogenesis
Trends Genet.
(2017) - et al.
Chiral forces organize left-right patterning in C. elegans by uncoupling midline and anteroposterior axis
Dev. Cell
(2010) The atypical cadherin dachsous controls left-right asymmetry in Drosophila
Dev. Cell
(2015)VSV-G-enveloped vesicles for traceless delivery of CRISPR-Cas9
Mol. Ther. Nucleic Acids
(2018)Mechanostress resistance involving formin homology proteins: G- and F-actin homeostasis-driven filament nucleation and helical polymerization-mediated actin polymer stabilization
Biochem. Biophys. Res. Commun.
(2018)
Moorean and Tahitian Partula tree snail survival after a mass extinction: new genomic insights using museum specimens
Mol. Phylogenet. Evol.
Paraxial left-sided nodal expression and the start of left–right patterning in the early chick embryo
Differentiation
Through the Looking-Glass, and What Alice Found There
From cytoskeletal dynamics to organ asymmetry: a nonlinear, regulative pathway underlies left–right patterning
Philos. Trans. R. Soc. Lond. Ser. B Biol. Sci.
Left-right asymmetry in embryonic development and breast cancer: common molecular determinants?
Curr. Med. Chem.
Nodal signalling is involved in left-right asymmetry in snails
Nature
Determination of left-right patterning of the mouse embryo by artificial nodal flow
Nature
Diversity and convergence in the mechanisms establishing L/R asymmetry in Metazoa
EMBO Rep.
Cytoskeletal symmetry breaking and chirality: from reconstituted systems to animal development
Symmetry
Early, nonciliary role for microtubule proteins in left-right patterning is conserved across kingdoms
Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U. S. A.
The development of handedness in left/right asymmetry
Development
It's never too early to get it right: a conserved role for the cytoskeleton in left-right asymmetry
Commun. Integr. Biol.
Evolution and distribution of left-handed and planispiral coiling in snails
Nature
The convoluted evolution of snail chirality
Naturwissenschaften
Chiral speciation in terrestrial pulmonate snails
PLoS ONE
Sinistral nematode population
Nature
Whole-body enantiomorphy and maternal inheritance of chiral reversal in the pond snail Lymnaea stagnalis
J. Hered.
Reversal of cleavage in a sinistral gastropod
Ann. N. Y. Acad. Sci.
On the inheritance of sinistrality in Limnaea peregra
Proc. R. Soc. Biol. Sci. Ser. B
Inheritance of direction of coiling in Limnaea
Science
The effect of coil phenotypes and genotypes on the fecundity and viability of Partula suturalis and Lymnaea stagnalis: implications for the evolution of sinistral snails
J. Evol. Biol.
Internal selection against the evolution of left-right reversal
Evolution
Maternal inheritance of racemism in the terrestrial snail Bradybaena similaris
J. Hered.
Genetic basis of racemism and ease of interchiral mating in a clausiliid species of snails
Molluscan Res.
Heterochirality results from reduction of maternal diaph expression in a terrestrial pulmonate snail
Zool. Lett.
Single-gene speciation: mating and gene flow between mirror-image snails
Evol. Lett.
High gene flow despite opposite chirality in hybrid zones between enantiomorphic door-snails
Mol. Ecol.
Chiral blastomere arrangement dictates zygotic left-right asymmetry pathway in snails
Nature
Evidence from reversal of handedness in C. elegans embryos for early cell-interactions determining cell fates
Nature
Left-right patterning in the C. elegans embryo: unique mechanisms and common principles
Commun. Integr. Biol.
Timing and mechanism of the initial cue establishing handed left–right asymmetry in Caenorhabditis elegans embryos
Genesis
The development of CRISPR for a mollusc establishes the formin Lsdia1 as the long-sought gene for snail dextral/sinistral coiling
Development
The cause of inverse symmetry
Anat. Anz.
Asymmetrical rotations of blastomeres in early cleavage of Gastropoda
Roux. Arch. Dev. Biol.
An unexpected twist: sperm cells coil to the right in land snails and to the left in song birds
Contrib. Zool.
Molecular to organismal chirality is induced by the conserved myosin 1D
Science
Cells with broken left–right symmetry: roles of intrinsic cell chirality in left–right asymmetric epithelial morphogenesis
Symmetry
Cell chirality: its origin and roles in left–right asymmetric development
Philos. Trans. R. Soc. Lond. Ser. B Biol. Sci.
Cited by (9)
Maternal control of visceral asymmetry evolution in Astyanax cavefish
2021, Scientific ReportsThe physical basis of mollusk shell chiral coiling
2021, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of AmericaMobilizing molluscan models and genomes in biology
2021, Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences