当前位置: X-MOL 学术Earth Sci. Rev. › 论文详情
Our official English website, www.x-mol.net, welcomes your feedback! (Note: you will need to create a separate account there.)
Comment on “Molecular hydrogen in surface and subsurface natural gases: Abundance, origins and ideas for deliberate exploration” by Alexei V. Milkov [Earth-Science Reviews, 230, 2022: 104063]
Earth-Science Reviews ( IF 12.1 ) Pub Date : 2023-02-04 , DOI: 10.1016/j.earscirev.2023.104338
Antonio Martín-Monge

In the article entitled “Molecular hydrogen in surface and subsurface natural gases: Abundance, origins and ideas for deliberate exploration”, Alexei V. Milkov leverages a large database to address the occurrence of molecular hydrogen (H2) in natural gases. The stated aims involve getting new insights into the mechanisms that lead to the production of H2 in geological habitats as well as producing tools for its deliberate exploration. This commentary discusses the definition and practical utility of some concepts employed by the author. It also provides observations suggesting that the diagnostic value of the isotopic signatures of H2 and associated gases is more limited than what Milkov (2022) contends. I further believe the examination of the hydrogen isotopic systematics in the CH4–H2–H2O ternary system presented by Milkov (2022) to be incomplete, and outline some potentially complicating factors to the proposed interpretations.



中文翻译:

对 Alexei V. Milkov 的“地表和地下天然气中的分子氢:丰度、起源和想法”发表评论 [地球科学评论,230,2022:104063]

在题为“地表和地下天然气中的分子氢:丰富、起源和有意探索的想法”的文章中,Alexei V. Milkov 利用大型数据库来解决天然气中分子氢 (H 2 ) 的出现。既定目标包括对导致地质生境中 H 2产生的机制获得新的见解,并为其有意探索提供工具。这篇评论讨论了作者使用的一些概念的定义和实用性。它还提供了表明 H 2同位素特征的诊断价值的观察结果伴生气体比 Milkov (2022) 所主张的更为有限。我进一步认为Milkov (2022) 提出的 CH 4 -H 2 -H 2 O 三元系统中氢同位素系统学的检查是不完整的,并概述了一些潜在的使所提出的解释复杂化的因素。

更新日期:2023-02-05
down
wechat
bug