当前位置: X-MOL 学术Journal of International Criminal Justice › 论文详情
Our official English website, www.x-mol.net, welcomes your feedback! (Note: you will need to create a separate account there.)
The Professional Market of International Criminal Justice
Journal of International Criminal Justice ( IF 0.753 ) Pub Date : 2021-09-08 , DOI: 10.1093/jicj/mqab062
Mikkel Jarle Christensen

This article analyses the division of labour and patterns of elite reproduction that characterize international criminal justice as a market of services. Using a sociological framework and building on empirical data on 996 professional agents, the analysis outlines how the market in and around the international criminal courts is structured by three different social groups that dominate the formal roles of judges, prosecutors and defence counsel. The article investigates the relative positionality of these groups highlighting the low degree of mobility between them. It also demonstrates the reproduction of male, global north professionals at the top of these groups, pointing towards intersectional dynamics of inclusion and exclusion in this market. To deepen the analysis of divisions of labour and reproduction of status, the article turns to a closer analysis of the patterns of expertise upon which elite status is built and how it links the three groups to the wider market of international criminal justice. The relations between the identified social groups, the elite of which have very particular characteristics dominated by global north professionals, educations and networks, structure a core part of the market of international criminal justice and formats the social fault lines behind its normative debates.

中文翻译:

国际刑事司法专业市场

本文分析了将国际刑事司法描述为服务市场的分工和精英再生产模式。该分析使用社会学框架并以 996 名专业代理人的经验数据为基础,概述了国际刑事法院内外的市场如何由三个不同的社会群体构成,这些社会群体主导着法官、检察官和辩护律师的正式角色。文章调查了这些群体的相对位置,突出了它们之间的低流动性。它还展示了男性、全球北方专业人士在这些群体中处于领先地位,这表明了该市场中包容和排斥的交叉动态。深化分工分析和地位再生产,文章转而深入分析精英地位所依据的专业知识模式,以及如何将这三个群体与更广泛的国际刑事司法市场联系起来。所确定的社会群体之间的关系,其精英具有由全球北方专业人士、教育和网络主导的非常特殊的特征,构成了国际刑事司法市场的核心部分,并在其规范性辩论背后形成了社会断层线。
更新日期:2021-09-08
down
wechat
bug