当前位置: X-MOL 学术European Journal of Probation › 论文详情
Our official English website, www.x-mol.net, welcomes your feedback! (Note: you will need to create a separate account there.)
Punitiveness of electronic monitoring: Perception and experience of an alternative sanction
European Journal of Probation Pub Date : 2021-09-16 , DOI: 10.1177/20662203211038489
Marina Richter 1 , Barbara Ryser 2 , Ueli Hostettler 3
Affiliation  

Electronic monitoring (EM) serves as an alternative sanction to incarceration. An important aspect that remains only scarcely debated in the literature is EM’s punitiveness and, more specifically, exactly how punitive EM is in comparison to different forms of incarceration. Responding to this gap, we propose a systematic meta-analysis of relevant studies that scrutinizes and compares different studies on EM and its punitive effects (or perceptions of its degree of punitiveness) in relation to incarceration. Ultimately, there is no simple and straightforward answer: EM’s level of punitiveness differs with the various sociodemographic variables of respondents included in the studies and the various characteristics of the penal system. It is necessary to assess the degree of punitiveness of EM to determine the conditions under and terms with which it should be applied, for example, as a humane substitute for incarceration or as an additional pain of the penal system.



中文翻译:

电子监控的惩罚性:替代制裁的感知和经验

电子监控 (EM) 是监禁的替代制裁。在文献中几乎没有争论的一个重要方面是 EM 的惩罚性,更具体地说,与不同形式的监禁相比,EM 的惩罚性究竟如何。针对这一差距,我们建议对相关研究进行系统的荟萃分析,仔细审查和比较关于 EM 及其与监禁相关的惩罚效果(或对其惩罚程度的看法)的不同研究。归根结底,没有简单明了的答案:EM 的惩罚程度因研究中受访者的各种社会人口变量和刑罚系统的各种特征而异。

更新日期:2021-09-16
down
wechat
bug