当前位置: X-MOL 学术Administration & Society › 论文详情
Our official English website, www.x-mol.net, welcomes your feedback! (Note: you will need to create a separate account there.)
A Good Servant But a Poor Master: The Side Effects of Numbers and Metrics
Administration & Society ( IF 3.121 ) Pub Date : 2021-09-08 , DOI: 10.1177/00953997211043830
Alexandre Asselineau 1 , Gilles Grolleau 2 , Naoufel Mzoughi 3
Affiliation  

A common practice in managerial and public service contexts is to quantity, calculate, and use numbers and metrics which provide a presumption of scientificity, a sense of measurability, objectivity, reliability, and precision upon which smarter decisions can be made. Besides providing a theoretical background, we analyze counter-productive effects of over-relying on numbers and metrics, notably in public administration. We discuss the following traps: preferring what is measurable over what is important, replacing the strategy by a measure and dehumanizing the decision making. We suggest some practical ways to facilitate a more parsimonious, smarter, and adequate use of numbers.



中文翻译:

好仆人差主:数字和度量的副作用

管理和公共服务环境中的常见做法是量化、计算和使用数字和指标,这些数字和指标提供了科学性假设、可衡量性、客观性、可靠性和精确性,可以据此做出更明智的决策。除了提供理论背景外,我们还分析了过度依赖数字和指标的适得其反的影响,尤其是在公共行政领域。我们讨论以下陷阱:偏爱可衡量的东西而不是重要的东西,用衡量标准代替战略,并使决策非人性化。我们提出了一些实用的方法来促进更简洁、更智能和更充分地使用数字。

更新日期:2021-09-09
down
wechat
bug