当前位置: X-MOL 学术ICSID Rev. Foreign Invest. Law J. › 论文详情
Our official English website, www.x-mol.net, welcomes your feedback! (Note: you will need to create a separate account there.)
The Concept of (In)admissibility in Investment Treaty Arbitration: Limited Yet Indispensable
ICSID Review - Foreign Investment Law Journal ( IF 0.976 ) Pub Date : 2021-03-02 , DOI: 10.1093/icsidreview/siab012
Saar A Pauker , Benny Winston

The concept of “admissibility of claims” in investment treaty arbitration is far from settled. Its very existence (and if so, its scope) has given rise to voluminous divergence of views amongst tribunals and scholars. Under the debatable assumption that admissibility is more discretionary than jurisdiction, various requirements, such as the requirement to have recourse to the local courts of the host State for twelve or eighteen months, have sometimes been characterized as referring to “admissibility” rather than as jurisdictional requirements. By contrast, other arbitrators and scholars contest the very existence of “admissibility” in investment treaty arbitration, and criticize any “downgrading” of jurisdictional requirement in order to “bypass” it. This article is focused on four particular issues, in light of recent cases decided since 2017, and in view of Söderlund and Burova's detailed contribution: waiting/negotiations and prior local recourse periods; shareholder's claims; exclusive contractual forum selection clause; and denial of benefits. It argues that the while the recourse to the concept of “admissibility” of claims in investment treaty arbitration should be limited and cautious, it is still indispensable.

中文翻译:

投资条约仲裁中(不)可接纳性的概念:有限但不可或缺

投资条约仲裁中“索赔的可受理性”的概念远未解决。它的存在本身(如果是的话,它的范围)已经引起了法庭和学者之间的巨大分歧。在可受理性比管辖权更具自由裁量权的有争议的假设下,各种要求,例如要求在 12 或 18 个月内向东道国当地法院求助,有时被定性为提及“可受理性”而不是管辖权要求。相比之下,其他仲裁员和学者对投资条约仲裁中“可受理性”的存在提出质疑,并批评任何“降低”管辖权要求以“绕过”它。鉴于自 2017 年以来判决的近期案件,本文重点关注四个特定问题,并鉴于 Söderlund 和 Burova 的详细贡献:等待/谈判和先前的当地追索期;股东的主张;排他性合同论坛选择条款;和拒绝福利。文章认为,虽然投资条约仲裁中诉诸“可受理性”概念应该是有限的和谨慎的,但它仍然是必不可少的。
更新日期:2021-03-02
down
wechat
bug