Professor Roger H. Mitchell was the second reviewer of our paper entitled “Types of Carbonatites: Geochemistry, Genesis, and Mantle Sources,” published in Lithos 386–387, 2021.

There were many great comments and comments in his review that I disagreed with and responded to those comments. The editors were pleased with my answers and, taking into account the excellent review of another reviewer, decided to publish the article. Professor Roger H. Mitchell was not satisfied with this decision and accused the editors of being wrong, although he had no right to do so and wrote a criticism. We took into account all the comments and remarks of the first reviewer and made the necessary corrections and respond to his criticism..

Roger H. Mitchell 教授是我们论文的第二位审稿人，题为“Types of Carbonatites: Geochemistry, Genesis, and Mantle Sources”，发表于 Lithos 386–387, 2021。

他的评论中有很多很棒的评论和评论，我不同意并回应了这些评论。编辑们对我的回答很满意，考虑到另一位审稿人的出色评论，决定发表这篇文章。Roger H. Mitchell 教授对这个决定并不满意，并指责编辑是错误的，尽管他无权这样做并写了批评。我们考虑了第一审稿人的所有意见和评论，并进行了必要的更正并回应了他的批评。