The Christian and Islamic doctrine of the virgin birth claim God asexually impregnated the Virgin Mary with Jesus, Mary's impregnation was fully consensual (virgin consent), and God never acts immorally (divine goodness). First, I show that God's actions and Mary's background beliefs undermine her consent by virtue of coercive incentives, Mary's comparative powerlessness, and the generation of moral conflicts. Second, I show that God's non-disclosure of certain reasonably relevant facts undermines Mary's informed consent. Third, I show that a recent attempt by Jack Mulder to rescue virgin consent fails. As divine goodness and virgin consent are more central to orthodoxy, Christians and Muslims have powerful reason to reject virgin birth.

基督教和伊斯兰教的处女出生教义声称上帝无性地使圣母玛利亚与耶稣怀孕，玛丽的怀孕是完全自愿的（处女同意），上帝从不采取不道德的行为（神圣的善良）。首先，我展示了上帝的行为和玛丽的背景信仰通过强制激励、玛丽的相对无能为力和道德冲突的产生破坏了她的同意。其次，我表明上帝不披露某些合理相关的事实会破坏玛丽的知情同意。第三，我表明 Jack Mulder 最近试图挽救处女同意的尝试失败了。作为神圣的善良和处女的同意在正统观念中更为核心，基督徒和穆斯林有充分的理由拒绝处女生育。