当前位置: X-MOL 学术International Journal of Art Therapy › 论文详情
Our official English website, www.x-mol.net, welcomes your feedback! (Note: you will need to create a separate account there.)
The effectiveness and contribution of art therapy work with children in 2018 -what progress has been made so far? A systematic review
International Journal of Art Therapy Pub Date : 2019-04-08 , DOI: 10.1080/17454832.2019.1574845
Liat Cohen-Yatziv 1 , Dafna Regev 1
Affiliation  

ABSTRACT This systematic literature review is a companion to our review of the effectiveness of art therapy with adult clients (Regev & Cohen-Yatziv, 2018) and aims to contribute towards the ongoing discussion in the field of art therapy on the effectiveness of art therapy in a wide range of child-aged clients. For this purpose, four major electronic databases were searched for quantitative articles relating to outcome measures in the field of art therapy with children from 2000 to 2017. A total of 13 articles responding to the inclusion criteria were identified and divided into three levels of evidence (Case-Smith, 2013). The results are organised into five clinical categories: trauma, special education and disabilities, non-specific difficulties, medical conditions and juvenile offenders. The potential benefits of art therapy in these five clinical populations is discussed and suggest that art therapy can be effective with children of the described categories. The limitations of this review and the current state of affairs are presented, alongside recommendations for future research to promote art therapy effectiveness research. Plain-language summary This article brings together all the research studies conducted so far on how helpful art therapy is for children. We use electronic databases to look at all the research published from 2000 to 2017. We found 13 articles which were relevant and classified under the following 5 headings: Art therapy with children dealing with traumatic events in their past. Four studies examining effectiveness have been conducted since 2002. These studies strengthen the claim that art therapy may help alleviate post-traumatic symptoms in children. Art therapy with children with special educational needs and disabilities. Four studies on effectiveness have been conducted since 2001. Most of the studies in this category suggest that art therapy has a positive effect on children with special educational needs and disabilities. Art therapy with children with no specific diagnosed difficulty. Three studies on effectiveness have been conducted since 2000. All three articles support the claim that art therapy may help children who are not diagnosed with specific difficulties but are faced with a variety of challenges in life. Art therapy with children dealing with medical conditions. Only one study fell into this category and addressed children coping with persistent asthma. This article lends some weight to the claim that art therapy may help children dealing with medical conditions, and specifically persistent asthma. Art therapy with juvenile offenders. Only one study fell into this category. This article supports the claim that art therapy may help juvenile offenders.In comparison to our recent review of research on how well art therapy works with adult clients (Regev & Cohen-Yatziv, 2018), we found far few studies in relation to children. Thus, we recommend further research on how well art therapy works with children.

中文翻译:

2018年儿童艺术治疗工作的有效性和贡献——目前取得了哪些进展?系统评价

摘要 这篇系统性文献综述是我们对成人客户艺术治疗有效性的综述(Regev 和 Cohen-Yatziv,2018 年)的补充,旨在促进艺术治疗领域正在进行的关于艺术治疗在治疗中的有效性的讨论。广泛的儿童年龄客户。为此,在四个主要的电子数据库中搜索了 2000 年至 2017 年与儿童艺术治疗领域的结果测量相关的定量文章。总共确定了 13 篇符合纳入标准的文章,并将其分为三个证据级别(凯斯-史密斯,2013 年)。结果分为五个临床类别:创伤、特殊教育和残疾、非特定困难、医疗条件和少年犯。讨论了艺术疗法在这五个临床人群中的潜在益处,并表明艺术疗法对所述类别的儿童可能有效。介绍了本综述的局限性和当前的事态,以及对未来研究的建议,以促进艺术治疗有效性研究。简明语言总结 本文汇集了迄今为止进行的所有关于艺术疗法对儿童有多大帮助的研究。我们使用电子数据库查看 2000 年至 2017 年发表的所有研究。我们找到了 13 篇相关的文章,并归入以下 5 个标题:儿童处理过去创伤事件的艺术疗法。自 2002 年以来,已经进行了四项检查有效性的研究。这些研究强化了艺术疗法可能有助于缓解儿童创伤后症状的说法。对有特殊教育需要和残疾的儿童进行艺术治疗。自 2001 年以来进行了四项有效性研究。该类别中的大多数研究表明,艺术疗法对有特殊教育需求和残疾的儿童具有积极影响。对没有特定诊断困难的儿童进行艺术治疗。自 2000 年以来,已经进行了三项有效性研究。所有三篇文章都支持这样一种说法,即艺术疗法可以帮助那些没有被诊断出有特定困难但面临着各种生活挑战的儿童。对患有医疗条件的儿童进行艺术治疗。只有一项研究属于这一类,并针对儿童应对持续性哮喘。这篇文章对艺术疗法可以帮助儿童治疗疾病,特别是持续性哮喘的说法给予了一定的重视。对少年犯进行艺术治疗。只有一项研究属于这一类。这篇文章支持艺术治疗可能有助于少年犯的说法。 与我们最近对艺术治疗对成年客户的效果的研究(Regev & Cohen-Yatziv,2018 年)相比,我们发现与儿童有关的研究很少。因此,我们建议进一步研究艺术疗法对儿童的效果如何。与我们最近对艺术治疗与成人客户合作效果的研究回顾(Regev & Cohen-Yatziv,2018 年)相比,我们发现与儿童相关的研究很少。因此,我们建议进一步研究艺术疗法对儿童的效果如何。与我们最近对艺术治疗与成人客户合作效果的研究回顾(Regev & Cohen-Yatziv,2018 年)相比,我们发现与儿童相关的研究很少。因此,我们建议进一步研究艺术疗法对儿童的效果如何。
更新日期:2019-04-08
down
wechat
bug