This research compares how English and French desisters experience and perceive probation supervision. In this qualitative study, desisters of both countries were interviewed to collect narratives of change within the context of punishment in the community. The aim of this research was to explore and compare the role of probation in desistance processes, in different national, socio-economic, and criminal justice settings. The findings demonstrate similarities in perceptions of probation officers as people with resources. Differences emerged in the types of resources engaged with and the perceived punitiveness of mandatory supervision.

中文翻译：

---

犯罪和缓刑监督的不足：比较英语和法语缓刑者的经验

这项研究比较了英国和法国后裔的经历和对缓刑监督的看法。在这项定性研究中，对两国的绝望者进行了采访，以收集社区惩罚背景下的变化叙事。这项研究的目的是探索和比较缓刑在不同国家，社会经济和刑事司法环境中的停战过程中的作用。调查结果表明，缓刑官对有资源的人的看法相似。在使用的资源类型和强制监管的惩罚性方面出现了差异。