当前位置: X-MOL 学术Foundations of Science › 论文详情
Our official English website, www.x-mol.net, welcomes your feedback! (Note: you will need to create a separate account there.)
Accepting the Exceptional?
Foundations of Science ( IF 0.9 ) Pub Date : 2021-04-10 , DOI: 10.1007/s10699-020-09762-1
Jochem Zwier

This commentary attempts to contribute to a further elucidation of Dominic Smith’s call for a rehabilitation of the transcendental in philosophy of technology. On the one hand, it focuses on why such a rehabilitation is deemed necessary, particularly in light of Smith’s diagnosis of a contemporary tendency towards reification and presentism. Postphenomenology is discussed as a challenge and invitation to further clarify the stakes. On the other hand, this commentary inquires into how Smith envisages the achievement of a rehabilitation of the transcendental. Further attention is given to Smith’s idea of a renewed sense of the transcendental. Following his own cues and situating this renewal in the philosophical tradition, the question whether the involved philosophical praxis should be primarily understood as political is brought to the fore. In so doing, Smith’s reading and extension of Luciano Floridi’s attempts to move beyond Kant receive special attention, since the transcendental is here understood in terms of conditions of feasibility. The challenge put to Smith is to contrast this approach with social-constructivist approaches on the one hand, and Stiegler’s thought regarding technics and the transcendental on the other. Finally, Smith’s commitment to taking exception is analyzed to ask how and which logic is at play there.



中文翻译:

接受例外?

这篇评论试图为进一步阐明多米尼克·史密斯(Dominic Smith)呼吁恢复先验技术哲学的呼吁做出贡献。一方面,它着重于为什么这样一个康复认为有必要,特别是在对当代倾向史密斯的诊断光物化presentism。后现象学被认为是一个挑战,并被邀请进一步阐明其中的利害关系。另一方面,这篇评论探究史密斯是如何设想实现先验者康复的。史密斯提出了一种新的先验意识的观念,这一点得到了进一步的关注遵循他自己的提示并将这种更新置于哲学传统中,所涉及的哲学实践是否应该首先被理解为政治性的问题就被摆在了首位。这样一来,史密斯对卢西亚诺·弗洛里迪(Luciano Floridi)超越康德的尝试的阅读和扩展得到了特别的关注,因为这里的先验者是从可行性条件的角度来理解。史密斯所面临的挑战是一方面将这种方法与社会建构主义方法进行对比,另一方面将施蒂格勒关于技术和先验思想的思想进行对比。最后,分析了史密斯(Smith)采取例外的承诺,以询问那里的逻辑方式和作用。

更新日期:2021-04-11
down
wechat
bug