当前位置: X-MOL 学术Journal of Chinese Philosophy › 论文详情
Our official English website, www.x-mol.net, welcomes your feedback! (Note: you will need to create a separate account there.)
RESPONSE TO WANG, HUANG, AND FRISINA'S COMMENTS ON THE GOOD IS ONE, ITS MANIFESTATIONS MANY
Journal of Chinese Philosophy Pub Date : 2020-10-10 , DOI: 10.1111/1540-6253.12411
Robert Cummings Neville 1
Affiliation  

This is a response to Wang, Huang, and Frisina's commentary on my book, The Good Is One, Its Manifestations Many. The response generally takes the form of re‐emphasizing my peculiar stresses on the Confucian tradition while applauding their alternative stresses. I particularly emphasize my metaphysical claims to defend my support for Xunzi; I set my philosophy of religion in the context of East Asian, South Asian, and West Asian philosophies. First let me thank the three commentators for taking my book so seriously and writing such stimulating commentaries.1 I learned from them all: it is a good thing I did not see them before the book was published because they would have caused me to make the book much longer than it is to deal with their questions. I especially thank Yong Huang for organizing this panel. I apologize to all for being prevented from attending because of the weather. Permit me to respond to each of the comments.

中文翻译:

回应王,黄和弗里西纳对善的评论是一回事,其体现有很多

这是对王,黄和弗里西纳对我的书《善是一,其表现很多》的评论的回应。回应通常采取以下形式:再次强调我对儒家传统的特殊强调,同时赞扬他们的另类强调。我特别强调我的形而上学主张,以捍卫对X子的支持;我以东亚,南亚和西亚哲学为背景来设定自己的宗教哲学。首先,我要感谢三位评论员如此认真地对待我的书并撰写了如此激动人心的评论。1个我从他们身上都学到了:在这本书出版之前我没看到他们是一件好事,因为它们会使我将书制作的时间长于解决他们的问题的时间。我特别感谢黄勇组织这个小组。我对所有人因天气原因而被阻止参加会议表示歉意。请允许我回应每个评论。
更新日期:2020-10-10
down
wechat
bug