当前位置: X-MOL 学术Social & Legal Studies › 论文详情
Our official English website, www.x-mol.net, welcomes your feedback! (Note: you will need to create a separate account there.)
Book Review: Elitism: A Progressive Defence
Social & Legal Studies ( IF 1.790 ) Pub Date : 2021-02-09 , DOI: 10.1177/0964663921994238
David Campbell 1
Affiliation  

This is a slight book and there is a question whether it is fair to review it in a journal such as this. Though it is very nicely presented, it is a short book, printed in a generous format on small pages. I imagine it would amount to a longer than average article in a UK law journal. It is also theoretically slight. It is a polemic written without a scholarly apparatus in a language which would not be accepted by a scholarly journal by an author that does not – some claims made are unfortunate – have a scholarly command of the history and theory of her subject (outside of aesthetics). Polemic is, of course, in principle perfectly legitimate, as is the absence of scholarly apparatus, but in this writer’s opinion a lack of scholarship itself reduces this polemic to a diatribe.

中文翻译:

书评:精英:渐进式防御

这是一本简短的书,有一个问题是否值得在这样的杂志上进行评论。尽管它的外观很好,但它还是一本简短的书,以慷慨的格式印在小页上。我想这将比英国法律杂志上的文章更长。从理论上讲也是轻微的。这是一部没有学术工具的论战性著作,其使用的语言不会被作者的学术期刊所接受,而作者不会对某些学科的历史和理论具有学术上的掌控力(某些主张是不幸的) )。当然,论辩在原则上是完全合法的,缺乏学术工具也是如此,但是在作者看来,缺乏学术性本身使这种论辩变成了a病。
更新日期:2021-02-10
down
wechat
bug