Discourse, Context & Media ( IF 1.858 ) Pub Date : 2019-12-16 , DOI: 10.1016/j.dcm.2019.100367 Jamie McKeown , Hans J. Ladegaard
The present paper examines the use of metadiscourse in the realisation of incivility in TV news discourse. We take empirical data from a UK Channel 4 News interview between TV journalist and author Cathy Newman and clinical psychologist and author Professor Jordan Peterson. Adopting a discourse analytic approach, five aspects of incivility are presented: intolerant response; ideological entrenchment; low oppositional literacy; the need to win; and, change of opinion condemnation. We show how metadiscourse is used to manifest incivility in a number of ways including to prioritise the current speaker’s foci over those of the interlocutor; to express metalingual commentary which negatively characterises the interlocutor's discourse; and, to express discourse norms which undermine the open exchange of ideas. We conclude by suggesting recommendations for future research.
中文翻译:
探索电视新闻话语中不活跃的元话语实现
本文探讨了元话语在电视新闻语篇中的不活跃中的应用。我们从电视新闻记者和作家凯西·纽曼(Cathy Newman)以及临床心理学家和作家约旦·彼得森(Jordan Peterson)之间接受英国第四频道新闻采访时获得的经验数据。采用话语分析方法,提出了五个方面的不活跃性:不宽容的反应;思想根深蒂固 较低的对立素养;获胜的需要;并且,对观点的谴责。我们将展示如何使用元话语以多种方式表现不言而喻,包括将当前说话者的焦点放在对话者的焦点之上;表达对对话者话语具有负面影响的标语性评论;并表达损害公开交换思想的话语规范。