当前位置: X-MOL 学术Discourse Studies › 论文详情
Our official English website, www.x-mol.net, welcomes your feedback! (Note: you will need to create a separate account there.)
Book review: Nguyet Nhu Le and Grace Qiao Zhang, Vague Language, Elasticity Theory and the Use of ‘Some‘: A Comparative Study of L1 and L2 Speakers in Educational Settings
Discourse Studies ( IF 1.871 ) Pub Date : 2020-07-27 , DOI: 10.1177/1461445620912042d
Zhongqing He 1
Affiliation  

In Chapter 15, the editors conclude the volume by proposing a topography of the said and the unsaid, where the individual’s actions are shaped by and shaping the landscape via participant-administered accountability. The collection presents a rich compendium of perspectives, methods and approaches of studying silence. Specially, Chapters 1–4 and 7 offer various signs of silence, which are entry points to linguistic analysis. The book covers analyses of wide-ranging topics in public, and especially in private spaces, including whistleblowers, paid domestic labor, gendered narratives and trauma survivors, which definitely broaden the boundary of research on silence. While quantitative studies on silence struggle for objectiveness (see Schröter and Taylor 2018), most studies in this collection intend to be subjective and reflective, showing the authors’ empathy overtly which greatly reduces the risks of reproducing repression. Instead of going with a rigid presentation format, chapters in this volume are diverse in style and it may take patience when some of them meander. In brief, the volume further increases the momentum of an exciting turn to silence and constitutes a valuable reference for researchers including sociolinguists, (critical) discourse analysts, conversation analysts, ethnographers as well as psychologists.

中文翻译:

书评:Nguyet Nhu Le 和 Grace Qiao Zhang,模糊语言、弹性理论和“Some”的使用:L1 和 L2 说话者在教育环境中的比较研究

在第 15 章中,编辑们通过提出所说和未说的地形来结束本书,其中个人的行为通过参与者管理的问责制来塑造和塑造景观。该系列提供了研究沉默的观点、方法和途径的丰富概要。特别是,第 1-4 章和第 7 章提供了各种沉默的迹象,它们是语言分析的切入点。这本书涵盖了对公共领域,尤其是私人空间的广泛话题的分析,包括举报人、有偿家务劳动、性别叙事和创伤幸存者,这无疑拓宽了沉默研究的边界。虽然关于沉默的定量研究为客观性而奋斗(参见 Schröter 和 Taylor 2018),但本集中的大多数研究都旨在主观和反思,公开地表现出作者的同理心,这大大降低了再现镇压的风险。本卷中的章节没有采用严格的演示格式,而是风格多样,其中一些章节蜿蜒曲折时可能需要耐心。简而言之,该卷进一步增加了令人兴奋的转向沉默的势头,并为包括社会语言学家、(批判性)话语分析师、对话分析师、民族志学家和心理学家在内的研究人员提供了宝贵的参考。
更新日期:2020-07-27
down
wechat
bug