当前位置: X-MOL 学术Sociological Theory › 论文详情
Our official English website, www.x-mol.net, welcomes your feedback! (Note: you will need to create a separate account there.)
Four Galore? The Overlap between Mary Douglas’s Grid-Group Typology and Other Highly Cited Social Science Classifications
Sociological Theory ( IF 3.694 ) Pub Date : 2020-09-09 , DOI: 10.1177/0735275120946085
Marco Verweij 1 , Petya Alexandrova 2 , Henrik Jacobsen 3 , Pauline Béziat 4 , Diana Branduse 5 , Yonca Dege 6 , Jakob Hensing 7 , James Hollway 8 , Lea Kliem 9 , Gabriela Ponce 4 , Inga Reichelt 10 , Mareile Wiegmann 11
Affiliation  

Recently, neuroscientists have argued that elementary ways of organizing, perceiving, and justifying social relations lurk behind the diversity of social life. In developing grid-group typology, anthropologist Mary Douglas proposed such universal forms. If these are universal, then we could expect other widely cited classifications to overlap with grid-group typology. We tested this expectation by examining to which extent the elements of Douglas’s typology overlap with those of 39 highly influential classifications proposed since 1970. We established overlap by calculating the interrater agreement among 11 coders. Fair to good interrater agreement, despite a complex coding exercise and minimal training, suggests that such overlap exists. Nevertheless, limits to our research design call for further studies. These findings should contribute to a rekindling of the question whether universal forms of organizing and perceiving social relations exist and to a further consideration of whether Douglas has managed to uncover these.



中文翻译:

四个嘉豪?玛丽·道格拉斯的网格组类型学与其他高被引社会科学分类之间的重叠

最近,神经科学家争论说,组织,感知和证明社会关系的基本方法隐藏在社会生活多样性的背后。在发展网格群类型学时,人类学家玛丽·道格拉斯(Mary Douglas)提出了这种普遍形式。如果这些是通用的,那么我们可以期望其他被广泛引用的分类与网格组类型学重叠。我们通过检查道格拉斯类型学的元素与1970年以来提出的39个极具影响力的分类的元素在多大程度上重叠来检验这种期望。尽管复杂的编码工作和最少的培训,公平的良好的人际协议表明存在这种重叠。但是,我们研究设计的局限性要求进一步研究。

更新日期:2020-09-09
down
wechat
bug