当前位置: X-MOL 学术Progress in Planning › 论文详情
Our official English website, www.x-mol.net, welcomes your feedback! (Note: you will need to create a separate account there.)
Comprehensive Assessment Method for Sustainable Urban Development (CAMSUD) - A New Multi-Criteria System for Planning, Evaluation and Decision-Making
Progress in Planning ( IF 6.063 ) Pub Date : 2020-08-01 , DOI: 10.1016/j.progress.2019.03.001
Fazia Ali-Toudert , Limei Ji , Linda Fährmann , Sina Czempik

Abstract This paper reports on the newly developed multi-criteria urban sustainability system CAMSUD (version 1.0) including the theoretical and analytical process underlying its development. CAMSUD stands for Comprehensive Assessment Method for Sustainable Urban Development. First, an extensive comparative analysis of five well-known urban rating systems is reported: CASBEE-UD, LEED-ND, BREEAM Communities, DGNB-NSQ and Green Star Communities. These rating systems are selected based on their widespread use, their numerous parallels in content, but also contrasting features, which give clear evidence on consensual and non-consensual items related to sustainability understanding and implementation. The analysis items revolved around their development drive, conceptualization, domain of applicability, technical content, practicality, measurability, and certification. Hence, this comparison identified the convergences and divergences of these systems and their potential for further optimization in view of highlighted strengths and weaknesses. Based on that analysis, the second part of the paper depicts the first version (1.0) of CAMSUD, including: 1. the prevailing key concepts in its development as well as its 40 compliance criteria structured in 8 thematic categories; 2. the logic chain of criteria interactions and their effects on an appropriate measuring and scoring. 3. the linkage between CAMSUD and the German sustainability-related legislation (laws, acts, standards and guidelines) as proof of compliance, and 4. the comparative analysis of a database consisting of 160 sustainable urban projects using CAMSUD 1.0 in order 1) to illustrate the handling of urban sustainability in practice and 2) to demonstrate its practical usability and to assess the current version for possible optimization. The motivation for and the outcome of CAMSUD is also to serve as a theoretical basis for a computational decision-making tool to be developed (ECAMSUD), which peculiarity is to manage topic, scale and time related criteria interactions responsible in probable redundancy or failure in scoring. By this means, CAMSUD strives to offer an alternative for a transparent and traceable framework for self-critical analysis and compromise finding when handling complex and cross-disciplinary urban development processes.

中文翻译:

可持续城市发展综合评估方法 (CAMSUD) - 一种用于规划、评估和决策的新型多标准系统

摘要 本文报告了新开发的多标准城市可持续发展系统 CAMSUD(1.0 版),包括其发展背后的理论和分析过程。CAMSUD 代表可持续城市发展综合评估方法。首先,对五个著名的城市评级系统进行了广泛的比较分析:CASBEE-UD、LEED-ND、BREEAM Communities、DGNB-NSQ 和 Green Star Communities。这些评级系统是根据它们的广泛使用、它们在内容上的众多相似之处以及对比特征来选择的,这些特征为与可持续性理解和实施相关的共识和非共识项目提供了明确的证据。分析项目围绕其发展动力、概念化、适用领域、技术内容、实用性、可衡量性、和认证。因此,这种比较确定了这些系统的收敛性和差异性,以及它们在突出优势和劣势方面进一步优化的潜力。基于该分析,本文的第二部分描述了 CAMSUD 的第一个版本 (1.0),包括: 1. 其发展中的主要关键概念以及 8 个主题类别中的 40 条合规标准;2. 标准相互作用的逻辑链及其对适当测量和评分的影响。3. CAMSUD 与德国可持续发展相关立法(法律、法案、标准和指南)之间的联系作为合规证明,以及 4. 使用 CAMSUD 1 对由 160 个可持续城市项目组成的数据库进行比较分析。0 以便 1) 说明在实践中对城市可持续性的处理和 2) 展示其实际可用性并评估当前版本以进行可能的优化。CAMSUD 的动机和结果也是作为将要开发的计算决策工具 (ECAMSUD) 的理论基础,其特点是管理主题、规模和时间相关的标准交互,这些交互负责可能的冗余或失败得分。通过这种方式,CAMSUD 努力为处理复杂和跨学科的城市发展过程时的自我批判分析和妥协发现提供一个透明和可追溯的框架的替代方案。CAMSUD 的动机和结果也是作为将要开发的计算决策工具 (ECAMSUD) 的理论基础,其特点是管理主题、规模和时间相关的标准交互,这些交互负责可能的冗余或失败得分。通过这种方式,CAMSUD 努力为处理复杂和跨学科的城市发展过程时的自我批判分析和妥协发现提供一个透明和可追溯的框架的替代方案。CAMSUD 的动机和结果也是作为将要开发的计算决策工具 (ECAMSUD) 的理论基础,其特点是管理主题、规模和时间相关的标准交互,这些交互负责可能的冗余或失败得分。通过这种方式,CAMSUD 努力为处理复杂和跨学科的城市发展过程时的自我批判分析和妥协发现提供一个透明和可追溯的框架的替代方案。
更新日期:2020-08-01
down
wechat
bug