当前位置: X-MOL 学术Music Perception › 论文详情
Our official English website, www.x-mol.net, welcomes your feedback! (Note: you will need to create a separate account there.)
A Reinvestigation of the Source Dilemma Hypothesis
Music Perception ( IF 2.184 ) Pub Date : 2019-06-01 , DOI: 10.1525/mp.2019.36.5.448
Douglas A. Kowalewski 1 , Ronald S. Friedman 1 , Stan Zavoyskiy 1 , W. Trammell Neill 1
Affiliation  

In a recent article, Bonin, Trainor, Belyk, and Andrews (2016) proposed a novel way in which basic processes of auditory perception may influence affective responses to music. According to their source dilemma hypothesis (SDH), the relative fluency of a particular aspect of musical processing—the parsing of the music into distinct audio streams—is hedonically marked: Efficient stream segregation elicits pleasant affective experience whereas inefficient segregation results in unpleasant affective experience, thereby contributing to (dis)preference for a musical stimulus. Bonin et al. (2016) conducted two experiments, the results of which were ostensibly consistent with the SDH. However, their research designs introduced major confounds that undermined the ability of these initial studies to offer unequivocal evidence for their hypothesis. To address this, we conducted a large-scale (N = 311) constructive replication of Bonin et al. (2016; Experiment 2), significantly modifying the design to rectify these methodological shortfalls and thereby better assess the validity of the SDH. Results successfully replicated those of Bonin et al. (2016), although they indicated that source dilemma effects on music preference may be more modest than their original findings would suggest. Unresolved issues and directions for future investigation of the SDH are discussed.

中文翻译:

源困境假说的再研究

Bonin,Trainor,Belyk和Andrews(2016)在最近的一篇文章中提出了一种新颖的方式,通过这种方式,听觉感知的基本过程可能会影响对音乐的情感反应。根据其来源困境假设(SDH),对音乐处理的特定方面(将音乐解析为不同的音频流)的相对流利性进行了愉快的标记:有效的流隔离会带来令人愉悦的情感体验,而效率低的隔离会导致令人不快的情感体验,从而导致(不)偏好音乐刺激。Bonin等。(2016)进行了两个实验,其结果表面上与SDH一致。但是,他们的研究设计引入了一些主要的困惑,从而破坏了这些初始研究为他们的假设提供明确证据的能力。为了解决这个问题,我们进行了Bonin等人的大规模(N = 311)建设性复制。(2016年;实验2),对设计进行了重大修改,以纠正这些方法上的不足,从而更好地评估SDH的有效性。结果成功地复制了Bonin等人的结果。(2016),尽管他们指出,音乐困境对音乐偏好的影响可能比他们最初的发现所暗示的更为温和。讨论了SDH尚未解决的问题和未来研究的方向。尽管他们指出,音乐困境对音乐偏好的影响可能要比他们最初的发现所暗示的更为温和。讨论了SDH尚未解决的问题和未来研究的方向。尽管他们指出,音乐困境对音乐偏好的影响可能要比他们最初的发现所暗示的更为温和。讨论了SDH尚未解决的问题和未来研究的方向。
更新日期:2019-06-01
down
wechat
bug