Abstract This work is a response to the discussion paper by Ghisu, T. and Cambuli, F. on our recent review paper (Ciu er al., 2019) published in Ocean Engineering. Two main reasons are given for the exclusion of parts of their papers from our review. First, our literature retrieval process was not able to use any published work from after our submission date, nor any work with considerable and inappropriate self-duplications under the academic criterion of citing references. Second, we are skeptical of Ghisu's “transient” model, which employed a multiple reference frame model to coordinate with unsteady Reynolds-Averaged Navier-Stokes equations and was unconvincing due to the lack of sufficient validation.

中文翻译：

---

回复：Cui, Y., Liu, Z., Zhang, X. and Xu, C 关于“用于 OWC 波能转换的轴流式自整流涡轮机 CFD 研究综述”的讨论

摘要 这项工作是对 Ghisu, T. 和 Cambuli, F. 在我们最近发表在 Ocean Engineering 上的评论论文 (Ciu er al., 2019) 上的讨论文件的回应。将他们的部分论文排除在我们的审查之外的主要原因有两个。首先，我们的文献检索过程不能使用我们提交日期之后的任何已发表的作品，也不能使用任何在引用参考文献的学术标准下有大量和不适当的自我复制的作品。其次，我们对 Ghisu 的“瞬态”模型持怀疑态度，该模型采用多参考系模型来协调不稳定的 Reynolds-Averaged Navier-Stokes 方程，并且由于缺乏足够的验证而没有说服力。